18Forty Podcast Ammiel Hirsch: 'What Did We Do Wrong?' Peoplehood and the Reform Movement [Denominations 2/5]
May 21, 2024
In this engaging discussion, Ammiel Hirsch, senior rabbi of Stephen Wise Free Synagogue and a prominent voice in the Reform Movement, delves into the complexities of Jewish Peoplehood. He addresses the role of the State of Israel within Jewish identity and how Reform Judaism is evolving its views on Jewish unity. Hirsch emphasizes the necessity of respectful dialogue amidst ideological divides, while reflecting on historical narratives that shape modern Judaism. His passion for fostering interdenominational relations shines through as he advocates for a unified Jewish community.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
A Book That Shaped A Young Listener
- David Byshevkin recalls reading One People, Two Worlds in high school and finding it eye-opening despite staying Orthodox.
- He credits the book for modeling respectful debate while exposing deep ideological divides.
Peoplehood Is Judaism's Core
- Ammiel Hirsch argues God's promise to Abraham establishes Jewish peoplehood as Judaism's foundational idea.
- He says this covenant anchors a communal mission that shapes Jewish identity and purpose.
Balance Universalism With Particularism
- Hirsch warns that losing either Jewish universalism or particularism distorts Judaism into something else.
- He insists Judaism's strength is its historical balance of caring for humanity and caring for fellow Jews.
