Pierre Rochard, cofounder of the Nakamoto Institute, and Francis Pouliot debate the value of the Stock to Flow model. They also explore hyperbitcoinization scenarios and discuss Bitcoin's demand and price dynamics. The podcast covers upcoming announcements and a low-fee stacking website, Bitcoin's potential impact on behavior and resource allocation, scaling the Bitcoin network, and the importance of infrastructure. They also promote Swan Bitcoin as the best platform for buying Bitcoin.
The stock-to-flow model offers quantitative analysis for Bitcoin's long-term price prediction, comparing its scarcity to other currencies like gold.
The stock-to-flow model serves better as an illustrative tool rather than a precise price prediction model, and actual availability of Bitcoin for purchase should be considered.
Cultural shift and infrastructure readiness are key challenges for widespread self-custody and hyper-bitcoinization to occur, requiring time and education.
Deep dives
Understanding the Stock-to-Flow Model
The podcast episode features a debate between Pierre Rochard and Francis Pouliot regarding the value of the stock-to-flow model. Rochard explains that the stock-to-flow concept compares the ratio of above-ground gold to the amount of new gold being mined, and claims that Bitcoin can be analyzed using this concept. He argues that the stock-to-flow model offers quantitative analysis for Bitcoin's long-term price prediction, despite its wide price range and limited data. Meanwhile, Pouliot expresses skepticism towards the model, suggesting that the stock-to-flow ratio is equivalent to time and that the decrease in supply does not necessarily drive demand proportionally. Both participants delve into the idea of scarcity and its impact on Bitcoin's price, highlighting the monetary policy and market dynamics associated with the halving. They also discuss the correlation between price and stock-to-flow, the usefulness of stock-to-flow in comparing currencies, and the adoption curve of Bitcoin.
The Value of Comparative Scarcity
Rochard emphasizes that the stock-to-flow model has value in comparing the scarcity of different currencies, such as gold and Bitcoin. He explains that Bitcoin's stock-to-flow ratio remains consistent over time, unlike gold, which changes depending on its market price. He suggests that this aspect of Bitcoin's scarcity makes it a powerful currency that will attract demand over time. Pouliot shares his thoughts on the stock-to-flow model, arguing that it serves better as an illustrative tool rather than a precise price prediction model. He highlights the importance of considering the actual availability of Bitcoin for purchase, as opposed to the total number of mined Bitcoins. The debate touches on the correlation between supply shock from halvings and price, potential marketing aspects influencing demand, and the overall adoption curve of Bitcoin.
Insights on Bitcoin's Monetary Policy
The episode's discussion delves into the engineering and economic aspects of Bitcoin's monetary policy. It speculates on how Satoshi Nakamoto might have determined the halving every four years, and the potential motivations behind this choice, including incentivizing quick network bootstrapping and subsidizing early adopters. The participants explore the correlation between halvings and price movements, the demand dynamics driven by scarcity, and the potential impact of the halving on miner behavior. They also touch on the idea of a Bitcoin future, addressing optimistic behavioral changes, such as increased adoption and healthier financial behavior, and potential negative behavior, such as attempts to cheat the system or exploit market manipulation.
The importance of cultural awareness and responsibility in Bitcoin adoption
One of the main challenges in Bitcoin adoption is the cultural shift required for individuals to feel comfortable holding and safeguarding their own Bitcoin. The speaker believes that it may take another 20-30 years before a global culture of self-reliance and responsibility is instilled, leading to widespread self-custody of Bitcoin. This cultural change is crucial for hyper-bitcoinization to happen, as currently only a small percentage of Bitcoin would be in self-custody if there was a massive adoption wave. Additionally, the speaker mentions that businesses and infrastructure are not yet ready for hyper-bitcoinization, and it may take a few more years to reach a stage where Lightning Network becomes a mainstream tool.
The scalability challenge of Bitcoin and the role of Bitcoin Core developers
The scalability challenge in Bitcoin lies more in the application and exchange layer rather than the Bitcoin core protocol itself. The speaker believes that Bitcoin core developers have done a good job optimizing the network, and the focus now should be on improving user experience and interface at the application and exchange layer. The speaker highlights that the main bottleneck is educating and encouraging individuals to safely hold their own Bitcoin, and that the transition towards widespread self-custody will take time, potentially around 20-30 years. On the topic of network scalability, the speaker expresses optimism towards Lightning Network, acknowledging the challenges it has faced but noting the positive developments in addressing UX challenges. However, the speaker emphasizes that hyper-bitcoinization should not happen immediately, as the current infrastructure and services are not prepared for a massive influx.
Pierre Rochard cofounder of the Nakamoto Institute and cohost of the Noded podcast and bitcoin evangelist at Kraken - and Francis Pouliot, founder and CEO at Bull Bitcoin join us in this one. We try to settle a Twitter debate between Pierre and Francis about the value of the Stock to Flow model. We polled our telegram chat room before and after the debate and there was a clear winner. We delve into several other topics as well, including various hyperbitcoinization scenarios.
Start buying your first Bitcoin in just minutes, with no fees on your first $10k. Search "Swan Bitcoin" in your app store or visit swan.com/app.
Put Bitcoin into your IRA and own your future. Check out swan.com/ira.
Swan Vault makes advanced Bitcoin security simple. Secure your BItcoin in a multisignature vault that requires 2 of 3 keys to access. You hold two keys for complete control, but you don't have to go it along. Learn more at swan.com/vault.
Swan Private helps HNWI, companies, trusts, and other entities go beyond legacy finance with BItcoin.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode