#125 Joseph Earl Thomas: Fatherhood, Regardless of Your Expectations
Feb 27, 2025
auto_awesome
Joseph Earl Thomas, author of the memoir Sink and the novel God Bless You, Otis Spunkmeyer, shares a candid look at his upbringing in Philadelphia. He reflects on the complexities of masculinity and fatherhood, revealing lessons from his grandfather about vulnerability and love. Thomas challenges conventional notions of success and discusses his struggles as a father of four, navigating the societal expectations placed on Black men. His insights create a powerful narrative about identity and the quest for connection amidst adversity.
Joseph Earl Thomas emphasizes that understanding masculinity should not conform to societal expectations of violence and aggression, which he found alien.
As a father, Thomas seeks to raise his children with awareness of privilege while shielding them from harsh realities he faced growing up.
Deep dives
Defining Modern Masculinity
Joseph Earl Thomas explores his understanding of masculinity, shaped significantly by his relationship with his grandfather rather than his biological father. Growing up in a tough urban environment, he faced fierce expectations regarding manhood, primarily framed by violence and aggression. Despite being raised in a household where these traits were emphasized, Thomas often found them alien and questioned their necessity. This internal conflict led him to seek a more nuanced understanding of masculinity, rejecting the idea that conforming to traditional standards is essential for self-identity.
The Impact of Environment on Identity
Thomas's memoir, Sink, chronicles his challenging upbringing in a working-class neighborhood of Philadelphia, where he constantly navigated fear and uncertainty. Surrounded by the complexities of life, including drug addiction and violence, he had to contend with the harsh realities that shaped his worldview. This backdrop led him to develop an acute awareness of gender roles and the lack of positive male role models in his community. Rather than conforming to societal narratives of overcoming adversity, Thomas emphasizes the importance of acknowledging and articulating the struggles faced by boys and young men of color.
Parenting Through a Different Lens
As a father of four, Thomas reflects on his early aspirations of parenthood, which came with the hope of imparting a sense of freedom and opportunity to his children. However, he confronts the stark difference between his childhood experiences and the life his children lead today, often filled with anxieties and pressures he wishes to shield them from. He grapples with the challenge of raising his children to understand the hardships faced by others while ensuring they recognize the privileges they enjoy. This delicate balance of nurturing and educating highlights his desire to break the cycle of pain that marked his upbringing.
Acclaimed author Joseph Earl Thomas spent much of his childhood watching everyone around him, trying to figure out where he belonged. He grew up attending public school in Philadelphia and constantly scanned the classrooms and hallways to avoid being beaten up by bigger, stronger boys. And throughout his adolescence Thomas was always trying to figure out what a man is and what a man isn’t. Then he realized that he shouldn’t even bother with those expectations.
On this episode of Paternal, Thomas recounts what life was like growing in the Philadelphia neighborhood of Frankford, what he learned about violence and vulnerability from his grandfather, his own anxieties as a parent to four kids, and why he’s reluctant to say his life story fits “the hero-story narrative thing” of Black kids finding success in America. Thomas is the author of the 2023 memoir Sink, which was dubbed “an extraordinary memoir of Black American boyhood” by the New York Times.