Starmer’s ‘weird’ week: from Liverpool to New York
Sep 27, 2024
auto_awesome
Miranda Green, a savvy political commentator, joins Robert Shrimsley, a political analyst focused on Labour's dynamics, alongside economics editor Sam Fleming, and foreign affairs expert Gideon Rachman. They dissect the unexpectedly muted atmosphere at Labour's conference following a big election win. Discussions include Starmer's efforts in New York to bolster international relations, the challenges of balancing fiscal policies with capital spending, and the impacts of good governance on public perception amidst rising populism.
Despite a significant electoral victory, the Labour Party's conference mood was subdued due to uncertainty and unfulfilled expectations among its members.
Keir Starmer's serious messaging on hard choices for governance may risk alienating potential supporters if not paired with tangible benefits.
Deep dives
Labour Party's Mixed Conference Atmosphere
Despite achieving a significant election victory, the Labour Party's conference presented a surprisingly subdued atmosphere, marked by a sense of uncertainty among its members. Observers noted a prevailing feeling that the party was not capitalizing on its success, as many newly elected representatives expressed difficulty in celebrating their historic victory. The negative media narrative surrounding issues like winter fuel payments and controversies related to party leaders contributed to this unusual mood, overshadowing the conference's optimistic backdrop. This dissatisfaction was further reflected in the conference's final act, where the leadership faced a defeat on crucial issues, leaving attendees pondering the party’s direction.
Concerns over Government Foundation and Policy Delivery
There are growing concerns within the Labour Party regarding the foundational policies of the new government and their effectiveness in addressing pressing issues. Critics emphasize that, despite winning the election, the party appears unprepared to deliver on its promises, potentially hindering its momentum. There is a belief that if the leadership fails to establish solid groundwork and address the public's needs, ongoing negativity could jeopardize their position heading into the next election. Comparing the current leadership to the proactive approach of Tony Blair's administration in 1997 highlights the urgency for Labour to not only create policies but also implement them swiftly.
Keir Starmer's Speech: Balancing Ideals with Voter Expectations
Keir Starmer's speech at the conference aimed to outline a vision for the Labour Party while addressing difficult choices the country must face, which he framed as necessary for true progress. However, the serious tone of his message contrasted with the lighthearted environment expected at such gatherings, raising questions about voter reception. His assertions that the party stands for hard choices and the state’s power to effect change sought to position Labour as the steward of serious governance. Yet, there are concerns that this emphasis on difficult solutions may alienate some potential supporters, especially if not accompanied by tangible benefits.
Uncertain Capital Spending Plans and Economic Strategy
Rachel Reeves hinted at a shift in Labour's approach to capital spending, suggesting potential changes to the party's borrowing rules to facilitate increased investment. This strategy aims at addressing the pressing need for growth through substantial infrastructural projects, though clarity on the specific allocations remains ambiguous. Internal discussions hint at the possibility of broadening the definitions of investment to incorporate various assets and liabilities, which could provide the government with more fiscal leeway. However, critics contend that without a clear plan detailing how this funding will directly impact public services and infrastructure, the party risks failing to regain the public's trust.
Labour’s conference in Liverpool should have been a celebratory event after its landslide win in the July election. Political editor George Parker, standing in for Lucy Fisher, is joined by Miranda Green and Robert Shrimsley to discuss why the mood was anything but triumphant. Plus, economics editor Sam Fleming explains how the government might increase capital spending despite Labour’s repeated warnings that the state coffers are empty; and chief foreign affairs commentator Gideon Rachman steps into the studio to assess Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s debut on the world stage at the UN general assembly this week. Lucy Fisher is back next week.
Sign up here for 30 free days of Stephen Bush's Inside Politics newsletter, winner of the World Association of News Publishers 2023 ‘Best Newsletter’ award.
Presented by George Parker. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. The executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Audio mix and original music by Breen Turner. The broadcast engineers were Rod Fitzgerald and Andrew Georgiadis. The FT’s head of audio is Cheryl Brumley.