David Labaree, an education historian and professor emeritus at Stanford, dives deep into the ongoing debate over high school exit exams in Massachusetts. He argues that high schools have never been effective at preparing students for future jobs, leading to a troubling focus on standardized testing. Labaree discusses how educational systems evolved from fostering citizenship to prioritizing workforce readiness, all while critiquing the implications of educational privilege and the need for more inclusive educational policies.
The debate over Massachusetts's high school exit exam reveals a significant public shift against standardized testing, highlighting concerns about equity and educational accessibility.
Education historian David Labaree emphasizes that high schools have historically failed to prepare students for future jobs while overlooking their broader role in social development.
Deep dives
The Stakes of Question Two
The discussion centers around Massachusetts Question Two, which proposes the elimination of the state's high school exit exam derived from MCAS scores. Maintaining this competency determination is argued to ensure that all students, particularly marginalized groups, are held to a common standard. Proponents of repealing the exit exam argue that it disproportionately affects students of color and low-income students, denying them diplomas even if they meet other graduation requirements. The debate is reflective of a larger conversation about educational equity and the role of standardized testing in assessing student readiness for graduation.
Public Sentiment on Standardized Testing
Despite a strong push from political leaders advocating for the retention of the exit exam based on equity arguments, public sentiment appears to be shifting against standardized testing. Many people express fatigue with the high stakes associated with standardized tests and their implications for students and teachers. Critics of the testing system argue that relying on test scores perpetuates a flawed system where educational resources and opportunities are not equitably distributed. This growing resistance highlights a disconnect between elite consensus and public opinion regarding education policy.
The Purpose of High School Education
The debate over the exit exam encompasses broader questions about the purpose of high school education itself. While some assert that the primary goal is to prepare students for the workforce, this perspective may overlook important social and personal development dimensions of education. Research indicates that traditional high school structures can sometimes fail to equip students with adaptive skills needed for future job markets. By challenging the narrow focus on standardized testing, advocates argue for a more holistic understanding of what it means to be a high school graduate.
Historical Perspectives on Education Criteria
The history of education in the U.S. indicates a shifting rationale regarding high school and its assessment methods. Traditionally, education was seen as a means of fostering citizenship rather than strictly job preparation, indicating a broader societal role for schools. Over time, as the industrial revolution transformed the workforce, educational goals began to align more closely with economic needs, ushering in standardized testing as a measure of student readiness. This evolution reflects ongoing tensions in educational policy decisions about balancing skills acquisition with the broader purpose of fostering informed and capable citizens.
Massachusetts voters will soon weigh in on whether to abandon the state’s de facto high school exit exam. That prospect has pitted elected officials and business leaders against teachers and their union, as well as a majority of voters, who’ve grown weary of schools’ focus on standardized testing. But the contentious debate also reflects a deep (and old) divide over the purpose of high school. We’re joined by education historian David Labaree who argues that high schools are not equipped (and never have been) to prepare students for the jobs of the future, and that policymakers and business leaders who insist on that goal have ended up dramatically narrowing the purpose of school.
The financial support of listeners like you keeps this podcast going. Subscribe on Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/HaveYouHeardPodcast
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode