Dr Joana Cook and Dr Shiraz Maher discuss the role of OSINT in understanding VEOs, the complexities of Islamist governance, challenges of analyzing propaganda, the importance of open source intelligence, and the use of technology by adversarial groups.
Open-source intelligence is crucial in understanding the governance strategies and propaganda of violent extremist organizations, highlighting the need for critical assessment and ethical research practices.
The use of AI and advanced technologies by violent extremist organizations poses challenges in discerning truth from falsehood, necessitating triangulation of multiple sources and critical assessment.
Deep dives
Understanding Violent Extremist Organizations
Violent extremist organizations (VEOs) are non-state groups that use violence to pursue their goals, primarily politically motivated. These organizations often have distinct ideologies that inform their actions. The rise of VEOs has led to a more splintered and dynamic threat landscape, with groups diversifying and proliferating in different regions. One key finding is that VEOs are increasingly focusing on governance and trying to establish control over territories and communities. They employ propaganda as a means to showcase their vision of governance, often highlighting social welfare activism to win support. Open-source intelligence plays a crucial role in understanding VEOs, by analyzing propaganda, narratives, news reports, and other open-source materials. However, challenges such as the graphic nature of some material and the rapidly changing online environment need to be navigated. Overall, open-source intelligence aids in uncovering insights into VEOs and their strategies, while also highlighting the need for critical assessment and ethical research practices.
The Complexity of Islamist Governance
The governance structures of violent extremist organizations are complex and dynamic, with each group having distinct nuances and ways of implementing governance. Islamist groups, in particular, have clear ideological foundations that shape their goals and actions. Propaganda produced by these groups offers insight into their vision of governance, highlighting social welfare activism as a means to win support and project their capabilities. Open-source intelligence, which includes analyzing propaganda, media reports, and narratives, can provide valuable information about how these groups present themselves and their governance models. However, the proliferation of misinformation and disinformation poses challenges, as the use of AI and advanced technologies can make it increasingly difficult to discern truth from falsehood. Triangulating multiple sources and critical assessment are necessary to navigate this complexity.
The Role of Open-Source Intelligence and AI
The expansive nature of open-source intelligence offers opportunities and challenges in understanding violent extremist organizations (VEOs). AI and advanced technologies can aid in analyzing vast amounts of open-source data to uncover patterns and insights about VEOs. For example, researchers have used open-source intelligence to study the demographics of individuals joining VEOs, particularly women and minors. There are significant ethical considerations when researching VEOs, such as ensuring researcher safety when analyzing graphic and violent propaganda. The evolving use of AI by VEOs also poses risks, as they may exploit AI technologies to disseminate misinformation and disinformation, exploiting grievances and targeting vulnerable individuals. The adversarial nature of this environment necessitates continuous innovation in technology, trade craft, and expertise to stay ahead of evolving VEO tactics and strategies in the open-source space.
The Need to Address Violent Extremism as a Persistent Security Challenge
Violent extremism remains a persistent security challenge that cannot be ignored, even as focus on state-on-state threats increases. VEOs continue to adapt, innovate, and operate in ungoverned spaces, amplifying their impact. Understanding VEOs requires deep expertise, trade craft, and a comprehensive approach that includes open-source intelligence analysis. As conflicts, food insecurity, and lawlessness persist in various regions, the incubation of VEOs is likely to continue. Government agencies and researchers need to prioritize the study of VEOs to effectively counter the evolving threat landscape and prevent future acts of violence.
Dr Joana Cook and Dr Shiraz Maher authors of 'The Rule is for None but Allah: Islamist Approaches to Governance' join Harry Kemsley and Sean Corbett to discuss the role that OSINT has to play in understanding violent extremist organisations and the challenges in doing so.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
