Explore the complex nature of European diplomacy during the Wars of the French Revolution, including the concept of compensation. Discover the changing dynamics of warfare and diplomacy during the Napoleonic era, as well as Russia's difficult position in defending the Ottoman Empire. Learn about Austria's decision to leave the war coalition and the collapse of Austria as their armies near collapse.
41:08
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Emperor Paul of Russia considered forming an alliance with France against Britain, but his assassination derailed the military alliance.
Austria faced a divided court and a precarious geopolitical position, leading to indecisive diplomacy and eventually a decisive French victory prompting them to seek peace.
Deep dives
Russian Withdrawal from the War
After some initial success for the coalition, Emperor Paul of Russia decided to withdraw his armies from the war, leading to talks for a peace treaty with France. The French invasion of Egypt and conquest of Malta had threatened Russia's desire for a permanent presence in the Mediterranean. However, with the French naval power in the region severely weakened and British troops occupying Malta and fighting in Egypt, the Russian threat from France seemed neutralized. Emperor Paul saw an opportunity to reorient Russian foreign policy and form an alliance with France against the British. Talks began, and there were even plans for a joint military invasion of British India. Unfortunately, Emperor Paul was assassinated, derailing any possibility of a military alliance. His successor, Emperor Alexander, sought a permanent peace treaty with France to secure diplomatic guarantees for minor Russian allies in Central Europe, but was unable to secure significant concessions from Napoleon.
Austrian Dilemma and Factionalism
Austria, facing a precarious geostrategic position and lagging behind other great powers in administrative and military reforms, found itself at a turning point in the war. Despite their desperate military situation, there was a faction within the Austrian court that believed continuing the war with France was their last chance to fight the republic on somewhat equal terms. They feared that surrendering to a peace treaty would only weaken Austria further, leading to future punitive treaties and diminishing their power. On the other hand, Archduke Charles and the pro-peace faction recognized the need to reform the Habsburg armies and advocated for a speedy peace so that reforms could begin. The court was divided, leading to non-committal and indecisive diplomacy. Eventually, the pro-war faction won out, resulting in the Battle of Hohenlinden and a decisive French victory, prompting Austria to seek peace.
Russo-French Negotiations and Peace Treaty
After Emperor Paul's assassination, the new Russian Emperor Alexander still sought some accommodation with France, but was unable to achieve a military alliance or significant concessions. The Russo-French treaty was based on trust and goodwill rather than guarantees. It addressed no territorial gains for Russia and, given the lack of leverage, provided no assurances of respecting each other's interests. France had measured the capabilities of Emperor Alexander and believed he could be influenced to favor their interests. The treaty established peace, but was fragile and lacked a robust framework for cooperation.
Austrian Defeat and Negotiations
Despite initial hope for a permanent peace treaty, negotiations between Austria and France were slow and unproductive. Austria's precarious geopolitical position and divided court hindered progress. The faction within the Austrian court opposing peace negotiations feared the return to pre-war terms, believing that continued war was their last chance to fight France on equal terms. Archduke Charles and the pro-peace faction recognized Austria's unsustainable position and the need for reform, and advocated for a speedier peace to enable those reforms. The Battle of Hohenlinden further solidified the need for peace, as it resulted in a decisive French victory and an Austrian retreat. In the end, Emperor Leopold II agreed to a ceasefire and sent representatives to negotiate a peace treaty based on Napoleon's proposed terms.