Julie Bindel speaks to law academic, Michael Foran who campaigns against the Gender Recognition Act. They discuss conflicts in women's rights, the impact of gender ideology, women's choices regarding headscarves, lack of forgiveness in politics, changing perspectives on feminism and the role of anger.
The Gender Recognition Act's implementation of self-identification could have adverse effects on women's rights, particularly for marginalized groups like Muslim and Jewish women.
Gender-neutral toilets that convert only women's spaces can be seen as indirect discrimination, removing resources exclusively available to women without similar changes for men, highlighting the need for considering the overall impact of such policies on marginalized groups.
Deep dives
Gender Recognition Act and its Adverse Impacts on Equality Law
The podcast episode explores the Gender Recognition Act in Scotland and the potential adverse impacts it could have on equality law. Michael Forran, a legal scholar, discusses how the bill's implementation of self-identification could negatively affect women's rights, particularly Muslim and Jewish women. He argues that while equality law should protect individuals undergoing gender reassignment, it should also consider the broader impact on women's rights and communities. By examining the conflicts of rights between women and trans women, he highlights the need for a nuanced approach to legal definitions of sex and gender.
The Impact of Gender-Neutral Toilets on Women
The podcast also delves into the issue of gender-neutral toilets and how they can inadvertently discriminate against women. Michael Forran explains how converting only women's toilets into gender-neutral spaces can be seen as indirect discrimination, as it removes resources exclusively available to women without a similar change for men. The discussion emphasizes the importance of considering the overall impact of such policies on marginalized groups like women, Muslim women, and Orthodox Jewish women, while also recognizing the rights of individuals undergoing gender reassignment.
The Cultural Influence on Societal Norms
The episode highlights the significance of cultural influence on societal norms and how it shapes perspectives on feminism and gender issues. Michael Forran acknowledges that one's understanding of feminism evolves over time and experiences. He shares his own shift in thinking, moving away from a skeptical viewpoint influenced by certain types of feminism prevalent in American discourse. The importance of addressing cultural norms and the impact of pornography, prostitution, and media on shaping oppressive expectations are emphasized as necessary considerations within feminist movements.
The Role of Anger and Accountability within Feminism
The podcast explores the role of anger within feminism and the need for accountability. Michael Forran discusses the complexity of anger as a valid response to injustice but highlights the importance of channeling it effectively. He acknowledges that while anger can lead to valuable insights and necessary challenges against systemic oppression, it is essential to differentiate between productive anger and destructive hatred. Additionally, the podcast emphasizes the importance of engaging in conversations, learning from past mistakes, and fostering alliances within the feminist movement.
Julie Bindel speaks to law academic, Michael Foran who is based at the University of Glasgow. Michael played a key role campaigning against Nicola Sturgeon who attempted to push through the Gender Recognition Act (GRA) – a bill allowing self identifying females into women's spaces. Michael wrote a legal paper to explain how the GRA could be in breach of equality laws – and bring down Sturgeon's campaign.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode