
The Thomistic Institute Virtue and the Meaningful Life – Dr. David McPherson
Dec 3, 2025
Dr. David McPherson, a Professor of Philosophy at the University of Florida, dives into the intricate relationship between virtue and a meaningful life. He critiques modern ethics for emphasizing happiness over meaning and defends a neo-Aristotelian perspective, arguing virtues are essential to meaningful living. McPherson explores strong evaluative meaning, martyrdom, and the tension between loss and virtue, emphasizing that true fulfillment arises from noble pursuits and theistic hope, striving for depth in the human experience.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Humans As Meaning-Seeking Animals
- Humans are distinctively meaning-seeking animals pursuing strong evaluative goods like the noble and the sacred.
- Contemporary virtue ethics often overlooks these meanings by treating flourishing like animal flourishing.
Happiness As A Meaningful Life
- An adequate neo-Aristotelian ethics should treat happiness as equivalent to a strongly valued meaningful life.
- This lets us reconnect virtue with an overarching life purpose rather than mere pleasure or desire-satisfaction.
Virtue Tied To Human Function
- Aristotle locates human function in rational social activity and links virtues to fulfilling that function well.
- Virtues of intellect and character are excellences that enable humans to live well together and reason well.






