The podcast discusses the tragic attack on Diane Whipple by her neighbor's dogs, raising questions about pet owner responsibility. It explores legal complexities and ethical dilemmas surrounding the case, including involuntary manslaughter charges and second-degree murder allegations. The episode touches on adult adoptions, therapy benefits, and summer camp challenges, shedding light on the consequences of owning aggressive dogs.
The Diane Whipple case sparked legal discussions on criminal liability for dangerous animals and responsibilities of pet owners.
Marjorie Noller's lack of remorse and accountability led to repeated parole denials, emphasizing the impact of behavior in legal proceedings.
Sharon Smith's successful civil suit set a legal precedent for same-sex partners in wrongful death cases, highlighting the case's broader implications.
Deep dives
The Tragic Death of Diane Whipple
Diane Whipple, a beloved lacrosse coach and athlete, was viciously attacked and killed by her neighbor's dogs in a horrific incident. The neighbors, Marjorie Noller and Robert Noel, who were lawyers, adopted the dogs from a notorious prisoner, Paul Schneider, known for his criminal activities. The dogs were bred for violence and had a history of aggression, even severing Robert's finger in a prior attack. Marjorie and Robert were charged with involuntary manslaughter and ownership of dangerous animals resulting in death.
Legal Battle and Sentences
Marjorie Noller faced multiple legal battles and convictions, including second-degree murder, which led to a sentence of 15 years to life. She persistently appealed her convictions with various outcomes from different courts, ultimately leading to her continued imprisonment. On the other hand, Robert Noel, her husband, received a much lighter sentence and suffered further hardships, including homelessness and health issues before passing away in 2018.
Claiming Responsibility and Parole Denials
During her multiple parole hearings, Marjorie Noller failed to show genuine remorse or take responsibility for the tragic events. Her lack of accountability, along with disciplinary actions in prison, resulted in parole denials. The parole board deemed her a danger to society, leading to repeated rejections. Despite attempts, Marjorie's sentences and convictions were upheld, highlighting the severity and complexity of the case.
Legal Precedent and Civil Suit
Sharon Smith, Diane Whipple's partner, successfully sued Marjorie and Robert for damages in a groundbreaking civil suit, setting a legal precedent for same-sex partners in wrongful death cases. Although Marjorie's actions brought tragedy, Sharon's efforts paved the way for legal recognition of domestic partnerships. The civil suit resulted in significant damages awarded to Sharon Smith, benefiting their community and legal landscape.
Significance and Lingering Questions
The Diane Whipple case left a lasting impact on legal and ethical discussions surrounding dog attacks, criminal liability, and legal representation. The tragic events raised questions about responsibilities, ownership of dangerous animals, and the intersection of law and personal relationships. Despite the complexities and controversial elements, the case brought attention to critical issues and legal precedents in wrongful death cases.
Ep 182: A woman is viscously attacked by a neighbors’ dogs and dies from her injuries. Her neighbor is sentenced to 15 years to life. But is this conviction too harsh for a pet owner?
Go to Shopify.com/crimewomen now to grow your business–no matter what stage you’re in.
Credits:
Written and Hosted by Amy Shlosberg and Meghan Sacks
Produced by James Varga
Audio Editor, Jose Alfonzo
Script Editor, Abagail Belcastro
Music by Dessert Media
Show your Support:
The easiest way you can support us is by leaving a review, telling your friends, sharing on social media or by sending us a note. We love to hear from our audience!
You can also support the show through the following ways:
Patron - ad-free shows starting at $2 a month, or upgrade to get an extra episode every month, exclusive AMAs with the hosts, lecture series on criminal justice, our true crime book club, and more! Check out our Patreon page for more info: https://www.patreon.com/womenandcrime
Apple Subscriptions - Regular Ad-free episodes and extra-exclusive episodes are now available through Apple’s podcast app for only $4.99 a month.
If you or someone you know is in a crisis situation, or a victim of domestic, or other violence, there are many organizations that can offer support or help you in your specific situation.