In this conversation, Sara Hobolt, a leading expert on European politics, and Paula Surridge, a political sociologist, dive deep into the evolving landscape of political labeling. They discuss how Britain's traditional left and right parties are struggling amid rising support for smaller parties, suggesting that these labels might be outdated. The duo examines how voters now seek alternatives that resonate with personal beliefs, driven by issues like immigration and social justice. They question whether a shared political sphere is feasible without common terms.
The decline of traditional parties in the UK suggests voters are increasingly seeking alternatives beyond outdated left-right political labels.
Emerging political movements focus on diverse issues, challenging the binary categorization of left and right within contemporary politics.
Deep dives
The Evolution of Political Labels
The podcast discusses the historical origins of political labels, particularly the terms 'left' and 'right,' which date back to the French Revolution when political factions were categorized based on their seating arrangements. However, these labels are increasingly viewed as outdated in the context of contemporary politics, especially as new parties emerge that defy traditional categorizations. In the UK, the decline in support for longstanding parties like Labour and the Conservatives indicates that many voters are seeking alternatives beyond a simplistic left-right framework. This shift reflects a broader trend in global democracies where voters are drawn to parties that offer innovative platforms devoid of the conventional political labels.
The Rise of Fragmented Political Ideologies
New political movements are challenging the traditional left-right spectrum by focusing on a range of issues unrelated to economics. For instance, parties like the Green Party prioritize environmental concerns, while Reform UK appeals to voters prioritizing immigration control. This fragmentation highlights a growing complexity in voter preferences, as many find it difficult to fit their political beliefs into a binary left-right model. Furthermore, some parties, such as Germany's Sarah Wagenknecht alliance, exemplify how overlapping issues can confuse traditional categorization by blending populist left ideologies with right-wing sentiments, particularly around immigration.
Voter Behavior and Increased Volatility
The notion of voters increasingly behaving like consumers in a market is discussed, signifying a shift toward more volatile and individualized political preferences. Voters today are less likely to feel a strong allegiance to any one party and are more inclined to switch their support among various political options based on specific issues. This detachment from traditional party loyalty has led to a surge in support for smaller parties and independents, particularly during recent elections. Consequently, voters often seek candidates who align closely with their unique preferences rather than subscribing to overarching party ideologies.
The Necessity of Political Labels
While the podcast acknowledges the limitations of left and right labels, it argues that these categorizations still serve a significant purpose in political discourse. Labels provide essential shorthand for voters, helping them make informed decisions at the ballot box by giving a general sense of where a party stands on various issues. Yet, as political dynamics evolve, it becomes increasingly critical to introduce additional axes that can encapsulate modern voter sentiments more accurately. Ultimately, maintaining a balance between traditional labels and the emergence of nuanced understandings of political beliefs is vital in navigating today's complex political landscape.
At the last General Election Britain’s traditional parties of left and right, Labour and the Conservatives, collectively amassed their lowest vote share ever - well under 60%. Three out of seven Brits voted for Reform UK, the Liberal Democrats, the Green Party or one of Britain’s many regional or nationalist parties. Does this result suggest that British politics is now too complicated to be understood by the labels left and right?
In Europe, some new parties like the German Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance have been labelled both far left and far right. Many similar parties seem to be having success by suggesting that they’re throwing off old political labels and offering something radically new in their place.
Studies say voters struggle to place policies along a left/right spectrum, and many don’t define themselves along left/right lines. So how can we have a shared political sphere if we can’t agree on terms? Are our political labels of left and right outdated? Are they due a rethink?
Presenter: Ben Ansell
Producer: Viv Jones
Editor: Clare Fordham
Contributors:
Sara Hobolt, Sutherland Chair of European Institutions at the London School of Economics and Political Science
Claire Ainsley, Director of the Project on Center-Left Renewal at the Progressive Policy Institute. and previously the Executive Director of Policy to Sir Keir Starmer
Giles Dilnot, Editor of Conservative Home and previously special advisor to James Cleverly at the Foreign Office and Home Office
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
