Orchos Shabbos Borer 5
Nov 21, 2021
The discussion dives into the complexities of what constitutes a mixture, with intriguing examples like stacked plates and clustered silverware. Exploring practical scenarios, the host clarifies when items truly mix versus act as mere obstacles. Listeners learn the rules around leftover utensils and the clever use of trickery to create immediate needs. The episode also touches on managing fridge items and the nuanced distinctions of organized versus piled contents. Engaging debates about seforim and the impact of external factors on mixture rules keep the conversation lively.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
When Is Something Truly A Mixture
- Borer applies only when items are perceived as a true mixture that changes their identity or function when together.
- Objects that remain distinct when adjacent (plates, books standing) are generally not considered mixed for borer.
Don’t Rescue Cutlery Under Trash
- Avoid pulling silverware out from under a pile of scraps unless you will use it immediately.
- If you will use it now, you may extract and even clean it as part of immediate usage.
Create Immediate Use When Needed
- Create an immediate use to permit extracting an item from a mixture, even if the need is manufactured.
- Performing a real action (e.g., make tea with the spoon) validates the extraction as allowed.
