The Jimmy Akin Podcast #047 TEAM EHRMAN: Did Mary Consent to Jesus’ Birth? - Jimmy Akin
11 snips
Aug 18, 2025 Robyn Walsh, a scholar of the New Testament and early Christianity, joins the host to unpack the complexities surrounding Mary's consent in the Annunciation. They dissect the Gospel of Luke, contrasting modern interpretations with biblical texts. Walsh highlights the implications of the term 'doulos,' suggesting a deeper understanding of Mary's acceptance beyond mere consent. The conversation also critiques applying ancient narratives to contemporary issues, bringing forth thought-provoking discussions on motherhood and spiritual freedom.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Clip Spurs The Episode's Question
- Robyn Walsh played a Joe Rogan clip about James Tallarico using Luke 1 to support pro-abortion views.
- Jimmy Akin immediately critiques Tallarico's recollection and frames the episode around whether Luke shows Mary consenting.
Don't Project Modern Questions Onto Ancient Texts
- Avoid reading modern political questions back into ancient texts without checking original language and context.
- Study the Greek and literary context before using biblical passages to support contemporary policy claims.
Gabriel's Message Is Joyful Announcement
- Luke frames Gabriel's message as overwhelmingly positive and anticipatory rather than a dry future statement.
- The angel presents Mary as chosen for a glorious role, not merely announcing facts without regard for her response.
