A Former School Shooter is a TikTok Star. Should He Even Be Allowed Online?
Oct 25, 2023
auto_awesome
Former school shooter turned mental health reform advocate, Jon Romano, discusses his presence on TikTok and the possibility of redemption for those who commit violent acts. The podcast explores restorative justice and racial healing while addressing the controversy of allowing Romano a public platform online.
The controversy surrounding John Romano's presence on TikTok raises questions about redemption, life online, and the potential for glorifying past violent actions.
The discussion highlights the tension between accountability, forgiveness, and the desire to control public narratives, underscoring the need for comprehensive dialogue and support structures for healing and transformation.
Deep dives
John Romano's Background and Advocacy Work
John Romano, a former school shooter, gained attention on TikTok after his release from prison, where he served 17 years for attempted murder and reckless endangerment. Since his release, Romano has been publicly advocating for mental health reform, prison reform, and gun safety. He shares his experiences, including details of his school shooting, to raise awareness and prevent future acts of violence. While some appreciate his efforts, others question whether he should have a platform, raising concerns about glorifying his past actions and the potential for attention-seeking behavior.
Controversy and Reaction
Romano's presence on social media, particularly TikTok, has sparked controversy and backlash. Critics argue that his platform should be taken away, pointing out the pain he caused during the school shooting and questioning his motivations. Others express concern about the monetization of his experiences and the potential harm caused by promoting a person with a violent past. The discussion around whether Romano should be allowed online highlights the tension between accountability, forgiveness, and the desire to control public narratives.
Examining the Role of Social Media and Accountability
The discussion extends beyond John Romano to the role of social media in shaping public discourse and granting platforms to individuals who have caused harm. Some argue that social media provides opportunities for formerly incarcerated individuals who committed violent acts to educate and deter future violence. Others raise concerns about the glorification and attention-seeking nature of such platforms. Questions arise about the appropriate response when someone has caused harm and whether exile from social media is the solution. Additionally, the need to foster comprehensive dialogue and support structures for healing, transformation, and accountability is emphasized.
The Potential for Restorative Justice
Exploring options for accountability and healing, restorative justice could provide a framework for John Romano to engage in a process that promotes understanding, repair, and transformation. Through a restorative justice approach, Romano could have guided conversations with those impacted, acknowledging the harm caused and seeking consensus on reparations. Virtual sessions, workshops, and counseling could be utilized to facilitate reflection and growth. However, meaningful change would require willingness, self-reflection, and an openness to accountability on Romano's part, along with the active involvement of a support network.
On today’s episode, Rachelle Hampton and Candice Lim dive into the saga of Jon Romano. At the age of 16, Romano walked into his high school with a shotgun in an attempt, he says, to commit law-enforcement-assisted suicide. Though no one was killed in the ensuing violence, a teacher was shot and injured. Romano pled guilty to attempted murder and reckless endangerment. He served 17 years in prison and was released in 2020. Since his release, he’s been a public advocate for mental health reform and gun control. Since 2022, TikTok has been a part of that advocacy work for Romano, a choice that landed Romano in the headlines once again after many decried his public platform of more than 275,000 followers.
Romano’s presence on TikTok and his large public profile raise thorny questions around the possibility of redemption and life online for those who commit violent acts. To help answer those questions, Hampton and Lim are joined by Dr. Teiahsha Bankhead, the executive director of Restorative Justice for Oakland Youth and an expert in restorative and racial justice.
This podcast is produced by Se’era Spragley Ricks, Daisy Rosario, Rachelle Hampton and Candice Lim.