Patrick J. Murphy, an Associate Professor of English and author, joins to discuss the haunting works of M.R. James, a renowned medieval scholar and ghost story writer. They explore how James's deep knowledge of medieval texts weaves authenticity into his eerie tales. The conversation touches on themes of cursed artifacts like a whistle, the intertwining of history and horror, and the impact of World War I on his narratives. Discover how James's academic background influences the chilling atmosphere of his timeless ghost stories.
M.R. James combined his expertise as a medieval scholar with supernatural fiction to create authentically chilling ghost stories that resonate deeply with history.
His narratives often utilized real medieval artifacts, infusing his tales with a credibility that enhances their unsettling nature and connectedness to the past.
The themes of James's stories reflect early 20th-century societal anxieties, exploring the delicate balance between scholarly curiosity and a deep respect for historical legacy.
Deep dives
M.R. James: Scholar and Storyteller
M.R. James was a renowned medieval scholar whose academic pursuits profoundly influenced his narrative style in ghost stories. He specialized in medieval manuscripts, church architecture, and historical texts, contributing significantly to the field through catalogs and translations. His deep engagement with medieval artifacts brought authenticity and texture to his supernatural fiction, allowing readers to feel a genuine connection to the history he portrayed. This unique merging of scholarship and storytelling made his ghost tales stand apart, as they reflect not just fictional scares but also historical realities.
Authentic Medieval Elements in Ghost Stories
James's ghost stories are noted for their rich details, which often draw from actual medieval artifacts and texts he encountered in his scholarly work. For instance, the story 'A Whistle and I'll Come to You, My Lad' features a significant artifact—a mysterious whistle—that connects to real medieval imagery, creating a tangible link between past and present. This detailed incorporation of authentic historical elements enhances the believability of his tales, making the supernatural feel more immediate and unsettling. Such authentic settings and objects serve not simply as backdrops but as integral components of the horror James crafts.
The Intersection of Antiquarianism and Professionalism
James's work reflects a tension between antiquarian interests and the emerging professionalism of academia in the early 20th century. While he was institutionalized within the academic system, his self-identity as an antiquary allowed him to navigate various scholarly fields freely, diverging from the specialization common among his peers. This duality encouraged a broader appreciation for historical artifacts, yet it also provoked anxiety regarding scholarly rigor and the worth of antiquarian pursuits versus modern academic disciplines. His works often illustrate a longing for a bygone era, where the study of the past could be undertaken with passion rather than strict professional constraints.
War Themes and Ghostly Warnings
The backdrop of World War I deeply influenced James’s narratives, infusing his ghost stories with themes of loss, duty, and haunting memory. In 'A Warning to the Curious,' the protagonist's discovery of an ancient crown serves as a catalyst for supernatural retribution, echoing the anxieties of a nation torn by conflict. This tale, set against the landscape of an impending invasion, metaphorically critiques those interested in the past for personal gain rather than for communal benefit. James subtly expresses regrets and dilemmas concerning the historical value of artifacts and their impact on national identity, highlighting the cost of curiosity amidst war.
Ghost Stories as Reflections of Anxieties
James's ghost stories are not just entertainments but manifestations of deeper societal anxieties regarding professionalism, curiosity, and the sanctity of the past. His characters often grapple with the consequences of their curiosity about antiquities, reflecting his concerns about the implications of digging into history without respect. The narratives explore how seeking knowledge can result in unforeseen repercussions, illustrating a cautionary tale over the pursuit of medieval artifacts. Through his evocative writing, James creates a lens into the fears of his time, making his stories resonate with audiences beyond mere fright.
The chilling ghost stories of M.R.James are as much a part of our Christmas television viewing as the King’s speech. But few realise that M.R. James was both a master of supernatural fiction and a distinguished medieval scholar. Dr. Eleanor Janega and Dr. Patrick J. Murphy discuss how M.R.James deep knowledge of medieval texts and artefacts, and his academic career, infused his stories with an authenticity and depth that set them apart from other works in the genre.
Gone Medieval is presented by Dr. Eleanor Janega and edited by Nick Thomson. The producer is Rob Weinberg. The senior producer is Anne-Marie Luff.
All music courtesy of Epidemic Sounds/All3Media
Gone Medieval is a History Hit podcast.
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
