Talk of the Devils: The Athletic FC's Manchester United show What does Mainoo’s situation say about modern Man United?
Dec 11, 2025
Laurie Whitwell, Manchester United correspondent for The Athletic, Carl Anka, a seasoned tactical analyst, and Andy Mitten, a longtime football journalist, dive into Kobbie Mainoo's uncertain future at United. They discuss whether he should be loaned out for more playing time and the challenges he faces in fitting into the current system. The panel also highlights young talent JJ Gabriel's impressive performances in the FA Youth Cup, pondering if he can live up to his idol Neymar. They further explore the changing landscape of United's academy amidst ongoing scrutiny.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Mainoo Symbolises Development vs. Pragmatism
- Kobbie Mainoo's playing future is a flashpoint showing tension between player development and the new regime's short-term plans.
- The club may wait until AFCON returns to reassess, but Mainoo likely wants a loan for regular minutes.
Amorim Setup May Stall Mainoo's Growth
- Carl Anka argues Manchester United under Rúben Amorim isn't the best environment for Mainoo's progression.
- He believes Mainoo probably needs a move or loan to kick on during these key development years.
New Regime's Scrutiny Of The Academy
- The new regime views the academy as underperforming and may prioritise external signings and commercialization.
- Yet Laurie notes several academy graduates (Mainoo, Garnacho) show the system can still produce sellable first-team talent.