Angela, a former debt collector with 15 years in the industry, shares her journey from collector to debtor after being banned for unethical practices. She reflects on the surprising realization that people struggle to pay their bills and the emotional toll of the job. Angela discusses the irony of now receiving calls from collectors herself and critiques their approaches. With a newfound perspective, she emphasizes the complexity of financial struggles and her aspirations for overcoming debt while navigating the moral dilemmas that plagued her former career.
Angela's journey from a debt collector who honed her negotiation skills highlights the emotional complexities and moral implications of the industry.
Recent shifts in debt collection practices and federal scrutiny reflect a changing landscape for consumers, impacting how debts are reported and collected.
Deep dives
The Decline of Debt in Collections
The percentage of Americans with debt in collections has decreased significantly, dropping from nine percent before the pandemic to five percent by late 2023. This change is attributed to various factors, including the pause on student loan payments and COVID-era financial support that provided individuals with extra funds to manage their debt. With over $20 billion generated by debt collectors in 2023, the industry has faced increased scrutiny from the Federal Trade Commission due to numerous consumer complaints about illegal practices. Notably, recent changes by major credit bureaus, which no longer account for medical debt collections under $500, have dramatically shifted the landscape of reported debts.
Insights from Angela's Collections Career
Angela, who built her career in collections, shared her journey of starting in the industry with little knowledge but a determination to succeed financially. Initially struggling to persuade debtors to make payments, she eventually honed her skills in negotiation, a process she referred to as the 'talk off'—a critical conversation between collector and consumer. Her experience highlights the complexities faced by debt collectors, who often encounter consumers in vulnerable situations, requiring them to adapt their approach to extract payments effectively. Angela's ability to read individuals quickly and navigate emotional conversations became key factors that paved her way to becoming a top collector.
The Ethical Dilemmas of Debt Collection
The podcast discusses the moral implications of debt collection work, especially as Angela reflected on the disconnect between her role and the human experiences of those she called. Despite the challenges, Angela believed her work served an important purpose in recouping lost funds for lenders, thus contributing back to the economy. However, she also described instances where she encountered heartbreaking stories from customers, such as a woman struggling with cancer who could not afford her debts. At times, Angela felt a personal obligation to help these individuals rather than strictly adhere to the collection process, underscoring the emotional weight carried by collectors in their daily interactions.
Angela's Transition and Subsequent Legal Troubles
After a successful decade in collections, Angela shifted her focus to family life and launched a payment processing business, only to face legal troubles from state regulators that accused her of participating in illegal collection schemes. Although she settled the lawsuit, the costs left her in financial distress, ultimately leading to personal debt and new challenges. As she navigated the complexities of her own debt collection, Angela's perspective changed as she became a consumer facing harassment from collectors. Her ongoing experience illustrates the cyclical nature of debt and collection, highlighting how individuals can transition from collectors to being collected from.
When Angela first started working at a debt collection agency, she says she barely understood what her job was. "I was so completely awestruck that people didn't pay their bills," she told Anna in 2019, when this episode originally aired. Angela ended up working as a collector for 15 years, working her way up and getting monthly bonuses for getting people to pay up. But then, in 2018, she was accused of being part of a scheme to collect debt in unlawful ways, and was banned from the industry for life. Soon after she started racking up debt of her own, and got calls from bill collectors. At first, she said, she would pick up the phone when collectors called, just to critique them. "Now I just block the number and move on," she said. "I will eventually get them paid off and until I can, there is no point in wasting their time."
Podcast production by Katie Bishop in 2019.
Death, Sex & Money is now produced by Slate! To support us and our colleagues, please sign up for our membership program, Slate Plus! Members get ad-free podcasts, bonus content on lots of Slate shows, and full access to all the articles on Slate.com. Sign up today at slate.com/dsmplus.
And if you’re new to the show, welcome. We’re so glad you’re here. Find us and follow us on Instagram and you can find Anna’s newsletter at annasale.substack.com. Our new email address, where you can reach us with voice memos, pep talks, questions, critiques, is deathsexmoney@slate.com.
