Kathleen Stock discusses Roland Barthes's Death of the Author, exploring how readers interpret texts, AI-generated content, and the impact on authorial intent and reader empowerment. The conversation delves into the evolving landscape of authorship and responsibility, urging a nuanced approach to understanding and judgment.
Challenges arise in distinguishing author's intent from reader-driven interpretations, exacerbated by social media.
Deep dives
Exploring the Death of the Author
The podcast delves into the controversial topic of the 'Death of the Author,' a concept popularized by Roland Barthes in 1967. Kathleen Storpe discusses the idea that the author's meaning in a text exceeds their intention, allowing readers to interpret texts independently. The discussion revolves around the philosophical debate between anti-intentionalists and intentionalists regarding the control of meaning in fiction.
Philosophical Reflections on Authorial Intent
The episode touches on the importance of understanding an author's intentions in interpreting texts. It argues that while readers can speculate and engage in multiple interpretations, acknowledging the author's intent enriches the understanding of literary works. The conversation highlights the value of uncovering an author's purpose, even amidst a backdrop of post-structuralist ideologies.
Navigating Literary Interpretations
The podcast explores how readers often engage with texts, projecting assumptions and integrating personal interpretations. It reflects on the challenges posed by current modes of communication like social media, where authorial intentions can be obscured, leading to misinterpretations. The episode underscores the complexity of distinguishing between the author's intended meaning and reader-driven interpretations.
Impact of Anonymity and Interpretive Perceptions
Anonymity in literary works and online interactions fosters a space where readers construct their own perceptions of authors and texts. The episode draws parallels between interpreting fiction and navigating social media contexts where limited information can lead to subjective and sometimes misconstrued understandings. It examines how anonymity influences reader projections in literary and digital realms.
Debating the Relevance of Authorial Intent
The podcast addresses the evolving dynamics of reader engagement with texts, challenging traditional and postmodern views on authorial intent. It delves into the implications of interpreting texts without considering the author's intent and its impact on literary analysis. The discussion highlights the balance between respecting authorial intentions and fostering diverse interpretations in literary discourse.
For our penultimate episode in this series David talks to Kathleen Stock about Roland Barthes’s idea of the Death of the Author (1967). Once very fashionable, the notion that readers not writers are the arbiters of what a text means has had a long and sometimes painful afterlife. As well as exploring its curious appeal and its persistent blindspots, Kathleen discusses her personal experience of how it can go wrong.
Two bonus Bad Ideas episodes for PPF+ subscribers – on Email and VAR – will be available very soon. Sign up now and get ad-free listening too! www.ppfideas.com
Coming Next: Helen Lewis on Mesmerism
Coming Soon: The Great Political Fictions Part 2, starting with Middlemarch