COP29: Why are developing countries so disappointed? | In Focus podcast
Nov 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Nagraj Adve, a founder member of Teachers Against the Climate Crisis, shares insights on the recent COP29 conference. He highlights the disappointment expressed by developing nations over inadequate climate finance commitments from developed countries, deeming them an 'insult.' The podcast dives into the complexities of new carbon market agreements and the ethical dilemmas they pose for indigenous communities. Adve also discusses the significance of the new methane reduction declaration and the critical need for fair funding solutions in the face of urgent climate challenges.
The COP29 conference ended without an effective climate finance agreement, leaving developing countries feeling burdened by inadequate financial pledges from wealthy nations.
New regulations for global carbon credit trading were established, raising concerns about their ethical implications and the impact on Indigenous rights and local communities.
Deep dives
Disappointment in Climate Finance Commitments
The COP29 climate conference concluded without a solid agreement on the new quantified collective goal for climate finance, leaving developing countries frustrated with a pledge of only $300 billion annually by rich nations instead of the expected $1 trillion. This commitment was perceived as inadequate, as developing countries were essentially instructed to find additional funding on their own. Analysts emphasized that this modest figure fails to address the significant financial needs for both mitigation and adaptation efforts, which are crucial for combating climate change in vulnerable regions. The expectation that developing countries should raise further funds voluntarily has been deemed an abdication of responsibility by wealthier nations.
Stagnation on Loss and Damage Fund Progress
The loss and damage fund, essential for assisting countries suffering from the impacts of climate change, saw little advancement during COP29, causing dismay among developing nations. Despite operationalization last year, the fund has only received around $731 million from various donors, which is inadequate in light of the extensive economic damages caused by extreme weather events, such as the devastating floods in Pakistan that affected millions. There were calls from various groups to include the loss and damage fund under a broader climate finance agreement; however, these proposals received scant attention. This lack of momentum indicates a persistently low commitment from developed countries to support those most affected by climate disasters.
Challenges and Concerns in Carbon Trading Agreements
The COP29 established new rules for global carbon credit trading, a move fraught with regulatory challenges and ethical concerns. Critics raised critical issues regarding the potential for double counting emissions reductions and the efficacy of many projects, claiming that numerous existing carbon offset initiatives lack permanence and additionality. Additionally, this system could undermine indigenous rights by allowing private capital or state entities to commodify natural resources, potentially displacing local communities. Advocates call for careful consideration of these implications to ensure that the transition to carbon markets does not further exploit vulnerable populations.
A Partial Victory in Methane Reduction Initiatives
Among the outcomes of COP29, the reduction of methane from organic waste declaration stands out as a positive development, with over 30 countries committing to address methane emissions from landfills. This initiative aims to mitigate the adverse environmental effects associated with methane, a greenhouse gas much more potent than carbon dioxide in trapping heat. Furthermore, the declaration opens opportunities for improving waste management practices, which can lead to better air and soil quality while also generating employment. However, while this declaration shows potential, further efforts are necessary to target larger methane emissions from the fossil fuel industry to achieve meaningful reductions.
The COP29 climate conference in Baku, Azerbaijan has concluded without a proper agreement on the New Quantified Collective Goal (NCQG) on climate finance. NCQG refers to the money that would be given by the developed countries to developing countries to meet their climate mitigation and adaptation transition goals. Instead of an NCQG deal, the rich nations have agreed to pledge $300 billion annually as a base figure to lead efforts – including by developing countries -- to raise $1.3 trillion annually from 2035. But developing countries have called this deal an “insult” as it seems to shift the onus of climate finance on to developing countries.
Apart from this, there was also an agreement reached on global standards for carbon markets and trading. Further, the COP29 Presidency launched the Reducing Methane from Organic Waste Declaration, which saw over 30 countries declaring their commitment to set sectoral targets for reducing methane from organic waste.
How do we assess COP 29 in terms of progress on climate finance? And how do we understand the outcomes with regard to carbon markets, the drawdown on fossil fuel consumption, and loss and damage funds?
Guest: Nagraj Adve, a founder member of Teachers Against the Climate Crisis (TACC).
Host: G. Sampath, Social Affaies Editor, The Hindu.
Edited by Sharmada Venkatasubramanian.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode