College Break - with Hadley Freeman, Noa Fay & Maya Ilany
May 3, 2024
auto_awesome
Award-winning columnist Hadley Freeman discusses her new essay on the left. Columbia and Harvard students share experiences amid campus protests. Political negotiations for a ceasefire deal and hostage release are highlighted. The rise of anti-Semitism and shifting attitudes towards Jews in America are explored. Conversation delves into fostering dialogue on anti-Semitism in academia and navigating Jewish identity in the US.
The shift on the left towards identity politics divided the world between oppressors and the oppressed, neglecting the complexities of different identities.
The October 7th massacre challenged the perception that Jews can never be victims, causing confusion and cognitive dissonance among some factions on the left.
Applying American racial dynamics to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict resulted in oversimplified comparisons and misunderstandings, fueling misconceptions and biases.
Deep dives
Shift towards racial identity politics on the left
The shift on the left from class-based politics towards race as the defining or organizing principle became prominent after around 2010-2012. The focus shifted towards identity politics, dividing the world between oppressors and the oppressed. This shift was influenced by the racial reckonings in America and resulted in a simplistic view of oppressor-oppressed dynamic, neglecting complexities and overlaps between different identities.
Jews as victims challenging the narrative
The perception that Jews can never be victims, limiting them from being targeted or hated, was a prominent feature of the left's ideological framework. However, the October 7th massacre showcased Jews as clear victims of violence, challenging the established narrative and requiring a reevaluation of ideologies to fit this new reality, which caused confusion and cognitive dissonance among some factions on the left.
Importing American racial dynamics to Israeli-Palestinian conflict
The attempt to apply American racial dynamics to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict led to oversimplified comparisons and misunderstandings. The framing of the conflict as white versus black, similar to American racial tensions, misrepresented the complexities and historical nuances of the long-standing Israeli-Palestinian issue, resulting in a flawed analogy that fueled misconceptions and biases.
Conflating Israeli policies with Jewish identity
The conflation of Israeli policies with Jewish identity contributed to a demonization of Jews as ultra-white, capitalist deceivers aligned with colonialist interests. This reductionist view ignored the diversity within Jewish communities and oversimplified Jewish identity to fit an ideological narrative, perpetuating harmful stereotypes and biases against Jews as a collective group.
The Rise of Anti-Semitism on Both Political Sides in America
Anti-Semitism has been observed among both the left and right political factions in America, with incidents like the Women's March organizers displaying anti-Semitic views and the Jews will not replace us rally during the Donald Trump era. Despite events like the shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue, there persists selective ignorance and bias against Jews in the U.S.
Challenges Faced by Jewish Communities and Reactions to Anti-Semitism
Jewish communities are facing increased anti-Semitic incidents, prompting individuals to grapple with their identity and safety. Instances of denial regarding anti-Semitism and the need for Jews to hide their religious symbols are highlighted. However, there are efforts within Jewish communities to strengthen their bonds and stand against discrimination, fostering unity amidst challenging times.
In a week when the Gaza conflict seemed to be relocated to the lawns of America’s Ivy League campuses, Yonit and Jonathan talk to Columbia student Noa Fay and to Maya Ilany of Harvard - followed by a conversation with award-winning columnist Hadley Freeman about her new essay on October 7 and the left. Plus: an update on renewed efforts to broker a ceasefire deal and hostage release, and the perennial indecision of Benjamin Netanyahu.
--
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/unholypodcast/ Join our Facebook group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1150578065793142
Join Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland for a special night of news and surprises—live on stage, June 8th 2025. If you’ve ever wanted to see the podcast come to life, now’s your chance. Reserve your seat now via the link—space is limited, and we’d love to see you there! https://bit.ly/UnholyLondonLive
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
