John Kaag, an expert on Henry David Thoreau's life and work, discusses Thoreau's critique of modern work, the connection between Bartleby the Scrivener and Thoreau's philosophy of nonconformity, the relationship between work and subjugation, and Henry's reflections on life and writing.
Thoreau questioned the concept of work, urging individuals to reflect on why they work and consider a simpler, more meaningful approach to making a living.
Thoreau criticized the capitalist system and advocated for meaningful work that fosters connection, dignity, and engagement with nature.
Deep dives
Thoreau's questioning of work
Thoreau questioned the concept of work, challenging its necessity and purpose. He saw work as burdened by meaningless tasks and labor contracts that were often exploitative. He believed that many jobs alienated individuals and failed to provide true fulfillment. Thoreau urged people to reflect on why they work and to consider a simpler, more meaningful approach to making a living.
The disconnect between work and happiness
Thoreau observed that people often tie their happiness to extrinsic goods, such as material possessions, which work is intended to provide. However, he argued that these goods often fail to bring lasting satisfaction, leading to disillusionment and a sense of emptiness. Thoreau encouraged individuals to detach work from the pursuit of these external rewards and to find meaning and contentment in the intrinsic goods of life, such as connecting with others, embracing simplicity, and engaging in hands-on tasks.
Critique of modern capitalist work
Thoreau criticized the capitalist system and its reliance on the subjugation of others for prosperity. He observed that many successful jobs depended on the exploitation of a large section of the population. Thoreau was concerned with the ethical implications of this dynamic and advocated for jobs that fostered connection and wholeness rather than alienation. He highlighted the importance of meaningful work that allows individuals to be fully present, maintain their dignity, and connect with nature and their own humanity.
Seeking wisdom and finding meaning in work
Thoreau's work emphasized the pursuit of wisdom and finding purpose in life. He believed that work should not just be a means of survival, but a way to understand oneself and the world. Thoreau sought to give a good account of his life through his writing, documenting his experiences and providing insight for future generations. He believed that philosophy and literature could serve as valuable tools for grappling with the complexities and existential questions of human existence.
It’s Labor Day week, 2023, and Henry David Thoreau is the heart of our conversation. It’s not with him, but it’s driven by his example: American thinking at its best on the matter of how to make a living.
John Kaag.
Have no doubt that the gabby man-about-Concord in the 1850s was a worker: expert surveyor, gardener, as many trades as fingers, he said, not to mention the writer of Walden and Civil Disobedience, of course, and a life journal that came to two million words. We read Henry Thoreau anew for his insight into our work, not his: the often fruitless, driven, underpaid labor of the 2020s, and, oddly enough, our midnight anxiety that ChatGPT could take it all away. This is a conversation in the Harvard Bookstore with our friend the philosopher John Kaag, who co-wrote the pungent and personal handbook titled Henry at Work.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode