Ruff translation, part one: do animals have language?
Feb 12, 2025
auto_awesome
Join Robert Berwick, a computational linguist from MIT, Federico Rossano, a cognitive science expert at UC San Diego, and Abby Bertics, a researcher specializing in non-human intelligence. They dive into the fascinating world of animal communication, comparing it to human language. The conversation explores whether animals possess their own languages and challenges our understanding of communication across species. Discover how AI could help decode these complex signals, reshaping our view of intelligence in the animal kingdom.
The podcast explores the ongoing debate about whether language is a unique cognitive ability of humans or a shared trait among species.
Advancements in AI are enhancing research into animal communication, especially focusing on domesticated pets' understanding of language-like associations.
Deep dives
The Significance of Language in Human Achievement
Language is a fundamental achievement that has enabled humans to excel in cooperation and shared knowledge. This collective success has led to profound societal advancements and innovations across various disciplines. The exploration into language also raises questions about the communication capabilities of animals, prompting research into whether animals possess their own forms of language. This inquiry attempts to challenge long-held perceptions of human superiority in linguistic abilities.
Historical Context of Animal Communication Studies
The study of animal communication has evolved significantly since the Victorian era when Charles Darwin introduced the idea that animals might share certain cognitive abilities with humans. Noteworthy efforts, such as attempts to teach chimpanzees human language through immersive studies, reflected the desire to connect with other species. However, many of these studies faced criticism over ethical concerns and questions regarding their scientific validity. As a result, scientists now approach the question of animal language with a more discerning perspective, focusing on the complexity of their communication systems.
Differing Perspectives on Language Definition
Two prominent theories regarding language emerged from experts in the field, reflecting contrasting views on its nature. Bob Berwick posits that language is an internal cognitive process unique to humans, emphasizing its structured and hierarchical qualities. In contrast, Federico Rossano argues that language primarily functions as a tool for communication, highlighting the significance of its external applications. This debate underscores the complex and multifaceted nature of language as a concept, revealing both internal and external dimensions.
The Role of AI in Understanding Animal Communication
Recent advancements in artificial intelligence open new avenues for deciphering animal communication. Ongoing studies involving dogs and cats, where they learn to associate vocalization buttons with meanings, aim to assess their communicative abilities. This innovative approach differs from past methods, as it works with domesticated pets that already engage with humans. Future research seeks to uncover the depth of understanding these animals possess regarding their emotions and experiences, potentially redefining what we consider as language.
Talking to animals has long been a human fantasy. But what is the nature of animal communication—and how does chirping and barking differ from human language? This is the first episode in a two-part series about animal communication and whether it could be translated in the age of AI. We meet a researcher who is leading the largest animal communication study ever attempted, and we ask whether language is a cognitive ability that’s unique to humans, or just one of many modes of communication dotted across the tree of life.
Host: Kenneth Cukier, The Economist’s deputy executive editor. Contributors: Robert Berwick of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology; Federico Rossano of the University of California, San Diego; and The Economist’s Abby Bertics.