PT Profit Podcast Email Marketing in 2026: How I Lost 15K Subscribers & What to Do Now
In this candid and deeply personal episode, Beverley Simpson shares her transformative experience of losing access to her 15,000-person email list—80% of whom were paying customers and clients—for 30 days. This isn't a doom-and-gloom story; it's a masterclass in identifying the difference between mistakes and misconceptions, diagnosing root problems, and building a bulletproof business in the online fitness coaching space. Beverley breaks down the cascading consequences of not understanding the real technical problem, the dangerous advice circulating online about email marketing, and the critical mindset shifts required to scale a profitable business. Whether you're just starting your email list or managing thousands of subscribers, this episode will fundamentally shift how you approach email marketing, audience diversification, and business resilience in 2026.
Key Discussion Points:
- 0:00-2:00 – Introduction and episode overview: Beverley shares what listeners will learn from her email list crisis
- 2:00-5:00 – Context on Beverley's business model: Building low-ticket funnels and customer-focused email lists (60-80% buyers)
- 5:00-8:00 – The crucial mistake in May 2025: Manually adding 2,000 people to a workflow, resulting in 4,000 emails sent in 30 minutes
- 8:00-12:00 – The cascading consequences: Open rates plummeting from 40-60% to 6-8% and the panic that followed
- 12:00-18:00 – The real problem revealed: Lack of email drip rate knowledge (emails need to send at 10-100 per minute, not all at once)
- 18:00-25:00 – Death by a thousand paper cuts: Months of attempting fixes without understanding the root cause
- 25:00-35:00 – Misconception #1: "Your email list is yours" – Why this is dangerous and what it really means
- 35:00-42:00 – Misconception #2: "Don't build an email list until you make a million dollars" – Why this advice is harmful
- 42:00-50:00 – Misconception #3: "One platform is enough" – The importance of diversifying your audience channels
- 50:00-58:00 – The technical nightmare: Changing domains, warming up IPs, and the complexity of email deliverability
- 58:00-65:00 – Christmas crisis: Getting bad advice from a "senior advisor" that made things worse
- 65:00-72:00 – The breaking point: Screaming in Voxer with her mentor and the decision to turn off all ads and emails
- 72:00-80:00 – The 30-day recovery: Turning off ads (which previously cost her from 50K to 2K in revenue), no fulfillment emails, and daily technical calls
- 80:00-88:00 – The solution discovered: Understanding email send rates and getting back on track by February 1st
- 88:00-95:00 – Guru energy and authority vs. expertise: Why perception matters and how to avoid being scammed
▶️ Ready to build your profitable online fitness business the right way? Join my FREE training where I show you the exact system I use to turn $9 into $50k months. https://ptprofitformula.com/simplescaling
// C O N N E C T Let's connect on Instagram! Send me a DM and let me know your biggest takeaway from this episode. Instagram: @BSimpsonFitness
// C O N T A C T For business inquiries, please visit: https://bsimpsonfitness.com