Holiday special: Meet JD Vance’s surprising European support network
Jan 3, 2025
auto_awesome
James Orr, an Associate Professor at Cambridge with strong ties to the UK's national conservative movement, and Rod Dreher, an Orthodox Christian writer linked to Viktor Orbán, dive into JD Vance's surprising rise in American politics. They explore Vance's transition from critic to supporter of Trump and how his Ohio roots influence his views. Jonathan Martin adds context on Vance's foreign policy ideas and the implications of his European connections, revealing a new breed of conservatism that blends traditional values with modern technology.
J.D. Vance's political evolution shows a shift from criticizing Trump to embracing his ideologies, influenced by European networks and thinkers.
Vance's integration of religious beliefs and compassionate conservatism suggests a new direction for American conservatism, focusing on economic inclusivity and family values.
Deep dives
J.D. Vance's Political Evolution
J.D. Vance's transition from a critic of Donald Trump to a devoted supporter exemplifies his complex political evolution. Originally from Middletown, Ohio, he emerged as a voice for the disillusioned working class, articulating their struggles in his best-selling memoir, 'Hillbilly Elegy.' This shift towards Trumpism is accompanied by his philosophical exploration influenced by advisors across the Atlantic. His newfound alignment raises questions regarding his earlier criticisms and suggests a strategic move to gain political traction in the current landscape.
Transatlantic Connections and Influence
Vance's connections to European thinkers reveal another layer of his political identity, notably through his ties with figures like Rod Dreher and the national conservative movement in the UK. These associations highlight his shift toward a European-style nationalism, marked by skepticism toward interventionist foreign policies. Vance’s stance on Ukraine contrasts with mainstream Republican views, expressing a cautious realism shaped by his military background and personal experiences. This European influence positions him within a broader ideological movement that seeks to redefine American conservatism.
The Intersection of Faith and Politics
Vance’s journey into Catholicism has profoundly shaped his political outlook, merging religious beliefs with conservative values. His emphasis on individual fragility and the importance of family reflects a compassionate conservatism that strives for a balance between social conservatism and economic populism. Vance recognizes the disconnect between conservative ideals and the realities faced by many American families, which he attributes to the failures of both liberal and conservative establishments. This perspective fosters a critique of traditional conservatism while advocating for a more inclusive economic platform.
Future Prospects and Political Impact
With aspirations that extend beyond his vice presidential candidacy, Vance is viewed as a potential heir to Trump's political legacy. His ability to articulate a distinct ideological vision while gaining the support of both traditional Republicans and new nationalists makes him a formidable figure. Analysts suggest he could shape future conservative policies by incorporating elements of populism and skepticism toward the established political order. Regardless of the outcome in the upcoming election, observers believe Vance's influence will continue to grow, potentially placing him on a path to future leadership roles.
To kick off the new year, we’re sharing a standout episode from our sister podcast, Power Play. EU Confidential will be back next week, but for now, join us for this deep dive into the rise of JD Vance.
From Hillbilly Elegy to vice-presidential candidate, JD Vance has come far since his hardscrabble roots in Ohio to shape the Trump doctrine for the millennial generation. He’s also gained notoriety for upping the temperature of America’s heated political discourse. But there’s also a philosophical side to Vance, shaped by a network of advisers and supporters on the other side of the Atlantic.
Host Anne McElvoy talks to two friends who have watched Vance’s rise closely: James Orr, a professor of religion at Cambridge University and a leading figure behind the National Conservative movement in the U.K., and Rod Dreher, a former American Conservative columnist who has links to Hungarian PM Viktor Orbán. Anne is also joined by Jonathan Martin, POLITICO’s politics bureau chief and senior political columnist, to reflect on Vance’s career prospects.