Exploring the flaws of self-help and pop psychology, the podcast discusses the failure to replicate experiments, the flaws in the self-esteem movement, the limitations of grit as a predictor of achievement, and the role of journalists in spreading misleading information in psychology research.
Read more
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Power posing exemplifies the problem with pop psychology and the tendency to embrace simple solutions to complex problems.
The self-esteem movement oversimplified complex societal issues and failed to address structural factors contributing to gaps and challenges.
Deep dives
The Rise and Fall of Power Posing
The idea of power posing, popularized by a TED Talk, suggested that adopting a powerful pose could make people feel more powerful. However, subsequent research revealed flaws in the original study, leading to doubts about the effectiveness of power posing. The phenomenon exemplifies a broader issue with pop psychology and the tendency to embrace simple solutions to complex problems.
Unraveling the Self-Esteem Movement
The self-esteem movement, driven by the belief that high self-esteem leads to success, gained popularity in the 1980s. However, research showed that the relationship between self-esteem and achievement was weak, with achievement often causing an increase in self-esteem rather than the other way around. The movement oversimplified complex societal issues and failed to address structural factors contributing to gaps and challenges.
The Flaws in Grit Research
Grit, the concept of perseverance and determination, gained attention as a predictor of success. Initially seen as a breakthrough, grit's correlation with conscientiousness was revealed, questioning its novelty. Moreover, research found that grit was less effective outside of limited settings and not easily increased. It highlights the danger of relying on simplistic solutions to multifaceted problems.
The Pitfalls of Pop Psychology
Pop psychology, with its $11 billion industry, aims to make psychological concepts accessible to the general public. However, its appeal often surpasses the scientific evidence behind the ideas. Issues such as biased reporting, flawed research, and disregard for replication contribute to the skepticism surrounding pop psychology. While psychology has valuable insights, critical thinking is necessary when evaluating popular claims.