In this lively discussion, Ed Buckner, a prominent secular organizer and author known for his work in religious liberty, dives into hot-button issues surrounding gender identity and ethics. He passionately argues against accusations of bigotry in debates inspired by biologist Jerry Coyne. The conversation explores the nuances of pronoun usage, the implications for transgender youth, and the ethical responsibilities in discussions about vulnerable populations. Humor and philosophical insights weave throughout, urging a deeper understanding of identity and public discourse.
Ed Buckner emphasizes the crucial role definitions play in discussions around ethics and biology, highlighting the subjective nature of ethical judgments.
The podcast showcases a clash between generational perspectives on language, particularly the use of singular they, reflecting broader cultural tensions regarding identity.
Buckner and Rabinowitz's debate illustrates the complexities of advocating for free thought while acknowledging the ethical responsibilities in discussions of trans issues.
Deep dives
Content Warning and Podcast Introduction
The episode begins with a content warning regarding the deliberate misgendering of a non-binary individual within the discussion. The host, Aaron Rabinowitz, introduces Ed Buckner, a secular organizer and author, to discuss their differing perspectives on a recent controversy involving the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF) and Jerry Coyne. Buckner expresses his long-standing support for FFRF and his disagreement with how the organization handled the publication and subsequent removal of Coyne's article. This episode aims to delve into the nuances of their disagreement, particularly concerning the ethics of public discourse surrounding gender identity.
Debate over Ethics and Definitions
Buckner emphasizes the importance of definitions in discussions about ethics and biology, noting that ethical judgments are made by everyone, regardless of credentials. The conversation reveals a clash between differing understandings of gender identity and biology. Rabinowitz argues that Coyne conflated ethical conclusions with biological claims, whereas Buckner defends Coyne's right to present his views. Both parties acknowledge the significance of holding differing opinions while highlighting the responsibility of public figures to articulate their positions thoughtfully.
Misgendering and Language Politics
The episode pivots to a discussion on the implications of misgendering and the evolving nature of language regarding pronouns. Buckner, identifying as an old-fashioned English major, shares his struggle with using singular 'they' as a pronoun, asserting his discomfort with adapting to contemporary language practices. Rabinowitz challenges Buckner's position, arguing that respecting individuals' self-identified pronouns is foundational to civil discourse and respect. This disagreement underscores the broader cultural tensions around language and identity, reflecting significant societal shifts.
Clarifying Anti-Trans Definitions
Buckner and Rabinowitz further examine what constitutes anti-trans discourse, debating the nuances surrounding definitions of harm and discrimination. Buckner asserts that concerns regarding privacy and safety in contexts like prisons should be addressed with care, acknowledging that trans individuals face discrimination but advocating for structure and definitions in sensitive settings. Rabinowitz counters that maintaining power over definitions can lead to unjust prejudice against trans individuals, arguing for nuanced understanding rather than broad categorization. Their dialogue illustrates the complexities entwined in articulating ethics within public policy.
Public Debate and its Implications
The conversation explores the implications of public discourse and debate surrounding trans issues, with both speakers reflecting on the potential for harm when discussing sensitive topics like sexual predation and gender identity. Buckner insists that the ability to critique and question definitions and policies is vital to free thought, while Rabinowitz warns against framing these discussions in a way that perpetuates harm to marginalized groups. The episode showcases the dichotomy of advocating for open debate while also recognizing the necessity of responsible dialogue in contemporary discussions about identity. This dynamic reveals an underlying tension in balancing free expression with the ethical implications of public discourse.
The Role of Activism and Accountability
Buckner addresses concerns regarding the potential mission creep of activist organizations like FFRF, arguing that advocating for trans rights can overlap with their core mission of promoting free thought. He critiques the decision to take down Coyne's article, suggesting that it could have beneficially remained as a point of contention for broader discourse. Rabinowitz pushes back, stressing that the maintenance of harmful narratives contributes to the stigmatization of trans individuals. Their discussion brings to light the challenges faced by secular organizations in navigating activism while maintaining their founding principles.
My guest this week is Ed Buckner, a secular organizer, former president of American Atheists. Ed is the author of the book In Freedom We Trust: An Atheist Guide to Religious Liberty, as well as the Substack blog Letters to a Free Country, where he recently posted a piece responding to my article “Biology is not Ethics” about the conflict around FFRF and Jerry Coyne's piece "Biology is not Bigotry". We discuss Ed's objections to my accusing Coyne of arguing for bigotry and discrimination, his refusal to use "they" as a singlar pronoun, and a variety of other topics related to trans-activism in secular spaces.
If you enjoy the show, please Like and Review us on your pod app, especially iTunes. It really helps!
This show is CAN credentialed, which means you can report instances of harassment, abuse, or other harm on their hotline at (617) 249-4255, or on their website at creatoraccountabilitynetwork.org.
Next Episode: Shorsey and Modern Masculinity with Ursa Wright
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
