Quite right! Q&A: Rory Stewart vs Dominic Cummings – the problem with political prophets
Jan 16, 2026
This discussion delves into the Green party's unexpected rise and its implications for the Labour party amidst accusations of betrayal. The hosts analyze Rory Stewart's clash with Dominic Cummings, highlighting the pitfalls of political forecasting and the issues of credibility among expert commentators. They also explore Labour's missteps regarding pubs, examining how rigid policies collide with the realities of rural life. The complexities of political allegiance and the struggle for genuine connections in modern politics are captivatingly unpacked.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Green Party As Genuine Realignment
- The Green Party's rise reflects a leftward realignment similar to trends in Europe between social democrats and urban, identity-focused Greens.
- Michael Gove and Madeline Grant argue Greens attract disaffected Corbyn supporters and urban youth, making them electorally viable beyond a protest vote.
Authenticity Trumps Policy For Some Voters
- Zak Polanski commands authenticity and loyalty that Keir Starmer lacks, drawing voters who value principled communication over policy nuance.
- Grant predicts Greens will win more councils and some parliamentary seats, harming Labour due to Starmer's U-turns.
Hipster–Hobbit Electoral Coalition
- The Greens combine seemingly incompatible bases: affluent NIMBY voters and progressive, student-heavy urban seats.
- Gove notes this 'hipster–Hobbit' alliance can persist while the party stays out of national power.
