In this thought-provoking conversation, Melissa Dougherty, author and YouTube personality, explores how the 19th-century New Thought movement has infiltrated modern Christianity. She shares her transformative journey from New Age beliefs to understanding the harmful effects of positive-thinking ideologies. Topics include the Law of Attraction, the subtle evolution of practices like yoga into spiritual commitments, and the merging of New Thought with prosperity teachings. Melissa also critiques contemporary self-help narratives, urging listeners to reflect on their spiritual practices.
The New Thought movement has subtly infiltrated modern Christian practices, leading to a significant departure from orthodox theology.
Melissa Dougherty highlights the problematic nature of the Law of Attraction by placing undue responsibility for life's challenges on individuals.
The seeker-sensitive church model, influenced by New Thought, prioritizes individual preferences over traditional teachings, threatening doctrinal integrity.
Deep dives
Introduction to New Thought
New Thought is characterized as a metaphysical and positive-thinking movement that influences many aspects of American society, including religion. This movement, which emerged in the 1800s, often replaces traditional Christian beliefs with a focus on self-empowerment and positive affirmation. Melissa Doherty reminisces about her own upbringing, reflecting on how these beliefs were mistaken for authentic Christianity, which highlights the subtle yet powerful infiltration of New Thought into everyday faith practices. She emphasizes the necessity of recognizing and addressing these influences, as they represent a significant departure from orthodox Christian doctrine.
The Law of Attraction and Its Implications
The Law of Attraction is a central concept in New Thought, positing that positive thinking can actively shape one’s reality. This principle asserts that individuals can attract positive or negative outcomes based on their thoughts and emotions, leading people to believe they have control over their life's circumstances. This idea can be problematic because it places the responsibility for misfortunes solely on the individual, effectively denying the complexities of life and suffering. Melissa points out that such beliefs can lead to a distorted understanding of personal accountability and divine providence.
Gnostic Roots and Foundational Beliefs
New Thought draws on Gnostic philosophies, where the concept of inner divinity plays a critical role. Proponents believe that ignorance of one’s inherent divine nature is the root of all sin, suggesting that individuals can achieve enlightenment through self-discovery. This perspective fundamentally alters the view of Jesus and Scripture, reducing them to mere symbols of one’s inner potential rather than authoritative figures of salvation. By divorcing religious teachings from their traditional contexts, New Thought creates a self-centered theology that emphasizes personal power over communal faith.
New Thought Influence in Christianity
The infiltration of New Thought into Christian practices is evident in movements such as Word of Faith, which emphasizes health, wealth, and positive confession. Doherty describes how many Christians unknowingly adopt New Thought principles while pursuing spirituality, ultimately compromising their theological integrity. This blending of ideologies often results in a skewed perception of Christian teachings, where the focus shifts from a communal, doctrinal faith to individualized, results-driven spirituality. The chapter warns Christians to be discerning about the influences shaping their beliefs to safeguard against doctrinal errors.
The Seeker-Sensitive Model and Its Problems
The seeker-sensitive church model is partially rooted in New Thought principles, reshaping church dynamics to cater more to individual preferences and less to traditional teachings. This approach emphasizes attraction to and inclusion of non-believers rather than nurturing existing congregants’ faith, resulting in a diluted gospel message. Melissa highlights that while some practices may seem beneficial, they can have long-term implications that shift the focus of worship from God to personal fulfillment. Recognizing these shifts is crucial for maintaining a doctrinally sound and spiritually substantive church environment.
Greg talks to Melissa Dougherty, author of Happy Lies: How a Movement You (Probably) Never Heard Of Shaped Our Self-Obsessed World, about how the 19th-century New Thought movement is still affecting the church today.
Topics:
Interview: Melissa Dougherty, author of Happy Lies: How a Movement You (Probably) Never Heard Of Shaped Our Self-Obsessed World (00:00)
