This podcast episode explores the disbelief and suspicion faced by Denise Huskins and Aaron Quinn after they were kidnapped and how they dealt with negative online comments and betrayal. It also discusses their emotional reunion, the investigation, evidence collection, and their journey of recovery, parenthood, and healing.
The Vallejo Police Department mishandled the case, doubting the victims' accounts and dismissing evidence, leading to public condemnation and online harassment.
The perpetrator, Matthew Mueller, was apprehended and convicted for kidnapping, assault, rape, robbery, and burglary, bringing a sense of closure to the victims.
Deep dives
Episode Recap
In this episode, Denise Huskins and her boyfriend, Erin Quinn, recount the horrifying experience of being kidnapped from their home in Vallejo, California. Denise was taken hostage while Erin was coerced into following the kidnapper's instructions. After 48 hours, Denise was released, but the couple faced disbelief and scrutiny from the police and public. The investigation eventually led to the arrest of Matthew Mueller, who acted alone in the crime. Denise and Erin share their journey to justice and the impact the ordeal had on their lives.
Inadequate Police Response
The Vallejo Police Department mishandled the case, doubting Denise and Erin's accounts and claiming that the incident was a hoax. The police failed to trace calls made by the kidnapper, disregarded evidence, and dismissed valuable information. The couple faced public condemnation and online harassment, further exacerbating their trauma.
Arrest and Legal Proceedings
Matthew Mueller, the perpetrator, was eventually apprehended and convicted for his crimes. The charges included kidnapping, assault, rape, robbery, and burglary. The sentencing brought a sense of closure to Denise and Erin, who delivered powerful victim impact statements in court.
Rebuilding and Advocacy
Denise and Erin have since focused on rebuilding their lives. They got married, had a child, and moved away from Vallejo. They filed a lawsuit against the city, reaching a settlement. The couple continues to advocate for victims' rights and tell their story, hoping to raise awareness and bring about change.
This episode picks up where 48 Hours, Part 1 left off. We suggest you listen to them in order.
When Aaron Quinn called the Vallejo police to report that his girlfriend Denise Huskins had been kidnapped, and went into the station for questioning, a detective told Aaron that he didn't believe him. When Denise was released after being held captive for about 48 hours, police didn't believe her either. It soon became clear that the police viewed Denise and Aaron as suspects, not victims.
Denise Huskins and Aaron Quinn’s book is Victim F.
This episode was originally released in 2021.
Criminal is going back on tour in February! We’ll be telling brand new stories, live on stage. You can even get meet and greet tickets to come and say hi before the show. Tickets are on sale now at thisiscriminal.com/live. We can’t wait to see you there!
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, members-only merch, and more. Learn more and sign up here.