Will Oremus, a technology writer for the Washington Post, dives into the shifting landscape of social media post-election. He discusses the rise of Bluesky and how it’s gaining traction as users flee from X, formerly known as Twitter. Oremus examines the nostalgia for earlier social media experiences and the challenges Bluesky faces in scaling while maintaining user engagement. He also contrasts Bluesky with Threads, highlighting the competitive dynamics shaping online discourse today. Can Bluesky fill the void left by Twitter? Tune in for insights!
Blue Sky's significant growth post-election reflects users' dissatisfaction with X and highlights the importance of community-focused platforms in today's social media landscape.
Changing dynamics on X under Elon Musk's leadership have led to increased polarization, with concerns over favorable representation for Republican voices alarming many progressive users.
Deep dives
The Rise of Blue Sky Amidst Social Media Evolution
Blue Sky has recently experienced significant growth, particularly in the wake of the 2024 election, with its user base nearly doubling from 13 million to 22 million. This surge reflects consumer dissatisfaction with existing platforms like X, especially after changes made under Elon Musk's leadership that shifted its focus and user dynamics. Users find Blue Sky appealing due to its chronological feed resembling early Twitter and a more intimate community feel, where interactions with familiar faces are prioritized. As the platform expands, the operational challenges of scaling—such as server demands and content moderation—have surfaced, posing questions about its sustainability and future viability.
Content Dynamics and Political Shifts on X
Since Elon Musk's acquisition of Twitter, now X, there has been notable concern about the platform's evolving political landscape, with research suggesting a shift towards favorable representation for Republican voices. Studies indicate that Republican tweets are garnering significantly more views, while Democratic engagement has dwindled, highlighting a concerning trend of polarization. Musk's implementation of policies that seem to favor conservative content, despite his public claims of promoting free speech, has left many progressive users feeling alienated. The ambiguity surrounding X's user metrics complicates the understanding of its actual engagement trends, raising skepticism about the platform's trajectory under its current management.
User Control and Community Focus at Blue Sky
Blue Sky distinguishes itself through effective user control features, notably a robust blocking mechanism that allows users to completely sever interactions with unwanted accounts. This contrasts sharply with X's policy modifications, which have frustrated users by allowing blocked accounts to still see their posts. Coupled with shared block lists, Blue Sky fosters a sense of community and shared responsibility in user moderation. Despite its rapid expansion, questions linger regarding Blue Sky's long-term sustainability as it navigates monetization and manages potential issues related to content moderation as its user base grows.
Whatever X is, it ain’t the Twitter so many users fell in love with. Since the election, Bluesky has been on the rise, but it’s still only a fraction of the number of users on Twitter—at its peak or even now—or even fellow upstart Threads.
Is Bluesky set to take over the role Twitter used to play, or is it just one of many networks in a Balkanized social media landscape?
Guest: Will Oremus, a technology writer for the Washington Post
Want more What Next TBD? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Evan Campbell, Patrick Fort, and Cheyna Roth.