The discussion explores the urgent need to reform the global trading system to support clean energy deployment amidst rising geopolitical tensions. It highlights the potential of trade policy to align with climate goals and emphasizes the importance of 'climate clubs' for international cooperation. Key challenges include navigating China's dominance in clean energy markets and addressing ethical considerations in trade policies. The need for standardized climate-related trade rules is stressed, particularly for developing countries striving for sustainability.
The podcast highlights the urgent need for trade policies that align with global climate goals to facilitate clean energy technology deployment.
Geopolitical tensions and domestic policies pose significant challenges to balancing competitiveness with the clean energy transition in global trade dynamics.
Establishing a new sustainable trade framework requires collaboration and clear standards to ensure environmental goals are met without triggering trade disputes.
Deep dives
Rethinking the Trade System
A fundamental rethinking of the trade system is underway, focusing on how it should evolve to balance economic progress with other policy goals, particularly climate change. Criticism of the trade system has grown due to its failure to address these other crucial issues adequately. The historical context showcases that, while economic integration has yielded benefits, rising geopolitical tensions and the embrace of industrial policies threaten the clean energy transition and contribute to higher clean energy costs. This conversation underscores the urgent need for trade policies that align better with global climate goals to drive the deployment of clean energy technologies.
The Role of the WTO
The World Trade Organization (WTO) plays a pivotal role in navigating the intersection of trade and climate policy. Recent initiatives emphasize the need for the trade system to adapt and support climate action, especially given that significant emissions are attributed to goods moving across borders. After working within the WTO, significant proposals for reform have emerged that aim to create a sustainable future while ensuring that the trade system does not undermine environmental progress. Cooperation among nations and aligned trade policies are seen as essential for achieving climate goals and ensuring equitable participation in the transition to clean energy.
Trade and Climate Day at COP 28
The inclusion of a trade day at COP 28 marked a vital intersection where discussions about climate change and trade policies converged. The significant revelation from the global stocktake showed that emissions continue to rise, prompting stakeholders to explore innovative solutions that can support both economic growth and sustainability. The need for enhanced financial mechanisms and corporate responsibility was articulated, but increased attention to trade's role highlighted its potential to facilitate the transfer of clean energy technologies globally. Aligning trade policies with climate commitments is seen as a major opportunity for accelerating progress in meeting net-zero emissions targets.
Navigating Geopolitical Tensions
Global trade dynamics are heavily influenced by geopolitical tensions, particularly concerning major players like China. Concerns over manufacturing standards, environmental policies, and supply chain resiliency often clash with the drive for competitiveness in clean energy technologies. Policymakers face the challenge of balancing the need for robust trade relationships while addressing domestic pressures to bolster local industries through industrial policy. This delicate balance will be critical in ensuring the clean energy transition occurs efficiently and sustainably while avoiding protectionist measures that could hinder progress.
Framework for Sustainable Trade
Efforts to establish a new framework for sustainable trade are taking shape, with an emphasis on partnerships and equitable standards among nations. Establishing clear sustainability standards and acceptable subsidy practices will be crucial for aligning market dynamics with environmental goals. Proposals like the carbon border adjustment mechanisms in the European Union illustrate attempts to level the playing field but must be handled carefully to avoid unintended trade disputes. Ultimately, creating a global trade system that prioritizes sustainability will require collaboration and adherence to shared commitments to foster a cleaner, more equitable future.
Following decades of economic integration, the cost of clean energy technologies have fallen sharply. But the rising costs of fragmentation, industry-friendly policies, and geopolitical tensions risk slowing the energy transition.
With the recent launch of the Trade and Clean Energy Transition initiative, the Center on Global Energy Policy has prioritized navigating the tensions between climate and trade, and focused on the potential to use trade policy as a tool to accelerate the pace of clean energy deployment.
So how can the rules of trade be better aligned with climate goals and policies? How can the international trading system be modernized to tackle a challenge like climate change? And how can countries reconcile low-cost, clean energy technologies, often made in China, with concerns about economic competitiveness, security, and supply chain resilience?
This week, we return to a conversation from earlier this year between host Jason Bordoff and Dan Esty focused on Dan’s career, his recent work at the World Trade Organization, and the intersection of climate policy and trade policy.
Dan is the Hillhouse Professor at Yale University and director of the Yale Center for Environmental Law and Policy. He has written numerous books on environmental responsibility and economic progress, including Green to Gold and Greening the GATT. Dan also served as commissioner of Connecticut’s Department of Energy and Environmental Protection from 2011 to 2014.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
