What Happened to American Conservatism? — with David Brooks
May 1, 2025
auto_awesome
David Brooks, a New York Times columnist and writer for The Atlantic, dives into the decline of genuine conservatism and the failures of elite institutions. He addresses the troubling moral decay in American politics and the challenges facing men and boys today. Brooks reflects on the exclusionary culture in education and argues for a return to character building in universities. He shares personal anecdotes about emotional growth, highlighting the importance of vulnerability and meaningful connections in fostering community and empathy.
David Brooks critiques the decline of true conservatism, highlighting a shift from principled governance to reactionary politics driven by personal interests.
He emphasizes the ongoing crisis of masculinity among young men, attributing it to traditional definitions and failures within the education system.
Brooks argues for a reinvigoration of elite institutions to include moral and civic education, fostering community engagement and character development.
Deep dives
Mental Health Awareness and Accessibility
Mental health awareness is increasingly pivotal, with discussions highlighting the need for widespread accessibility to therapy. Services like BetterHelp provide online therapy options, allowing individuals to choose from over 30,000 therapists, making mental health resources more convenient and affordable. This platform empowers users to switch therapists easily at no additional cost, promoting a more flexible approach to mental wellness. Such accessibility can aid in breaking down the stigma surrounding mental health, encouraging more individuals to seek help.
Reflecting on Personal Experiences
The speaker shares personal anecdotes about a weekend spent in London, illustrating a profound connection with family and the joy of shared experiences. Engaging in outdoor activities, such as working out with his son and enjoying food together, highlights the importance of familial bonds. The speaker's reflections on cultural encounters and social interactions also emphasize the beauty of simple joys in life, reinforcing that moments of connection can provide comfort and happiness. This narrative illustrates how meaningful relationships enhance well-being, especially amidst challenging times.
Political Commentary and Leadership Perspectives
The political landscape is critiqued, particularly focusing on leadership and the current state of governance. The speaker discusses the perceived decline in effective leadership, drawing attention to a shift from principled conservatism to reactionary politics driven by personal agendas. There is a call for more responsible and compassionate leadership, suggesting that many Fortune 500 CEOs and political figures are beginning to recognize the need for change. This changing dynamic signals a potential shift in public sentiment, advocating for more thoughtful approaches to governance and policy.
The Crisis of Masculinity
The conversation explores the ongoing crisis of masculinity and its societal implications, particularly concerning young men. The speaker highlights a growing disconnection among males and how traditional definitions of masculinity may contribute to feelings of purposelessness. Richard Reeves' insights suggest that the education system often fails to cater to boys, exacerbating this crisis. The need for outlets that foster self-improvement and a sense of purpose is emphasized, proposing that adventure and challenges can play significant roles in young men's development.
The Role of Institutions in Personal Growth
A discussion on the importance of institutions in fostering personal growth and community engagement is presented, focusing on the need for moral formation. The shift in universities from moral and character education to career-focused, politically charged environments is critiqued. There is an argument for redefining educational goals to include moral and civic responsibilities, encouraging students to develop a well-rounded perspective on life. By reintegrating discussions on character and community service, institutions can create a more engaged and empathetic future generation.
David Brooks, New York Times columnist and writer for The Atlantic, joins Scott to discuss the decline of true conservatism, the failures of elite institutions, the moral decay fueling American politics, and the crisis facing men and boys.
