9.2 – Equity, Equality and Lizard People: when right wing politics masquerade as left wing politics
Aug 10, 2023
auto_awesome
Delve into the provocative shift from 'equality' to 'equity' and how it influences political discourse. Discover the troubling dynamics between liberty and wealth disparity, and the ways established powers hijack progressive movements. Analyze the impact of discrimination on economic exploitation, and how superficial reforms miss the mark. Explore the complexities of college admissions, revealing biases against underprivileged students. Finally, the call for economic unity challenges divisive politics, inviting a deeper conversation on class and solidarity.
The podcast critiques the shift from 'equality' to 'equity' as a strategy by elites to maintain economic inequality under the guise of social justice.
It emphasizes that true liberty is intrinsically linked to political and economic equality, challenging the dichotomy between these concepts.
Identity politics is examined as a divisive factor that detracts from addressing economic inequalities, hindering the formation of broader coalitions against the status quo.
Deep dives
The Shift from Equality to Equity
The replacement of the term 'equality' with 'equity' is highlighted as a significant change in political discourse. This shift allows for ideologies promoting economic inequality to be masked under the guise of social justice. By using the term equity, institutions can create divisions among different racial, ethnic, and gender groups, causing conflicts that detract from collective efforts to challenge the power structures. The argument is made that this rebranding serves as a facade for right-wing politics dressed in left-wing principles.
Historical Context of Left vs Right Ideologies
The distinctions between political left and right are rooted in historical struggles for equality versus hierarchy. The left has traditionally championed liberty and equality, while the right has favored maintaining established hierarchies and privileges. This ideological framework, originating from the French Revolution, is explored to understand how democratic ideals on the left have been represented. The concept of political equality is emphasized as a core tenet of leftist thought, contrary to the authoritarian tendencies observed in right-wing politics.
Rousseau's Influence on Concepts of Liberty and Equality
Jean-Jacques Rousseau's philosophy is referenced to argue that true liberty is inextricably linked with equality. Rousseau posited that political equality and a degree of economic equality are essential for freedom to flourish. This notion challenges the common belief that liberty and equality are opposing forces. By emphasizing that without economic equity, liberty remains undermined, the argument reinforces the necessity of a society structured around fairness in wealth distribution.
The Political Spectrum Confusion and Its Implications
The podcast discusses how modern definitions of left and right have become convoluted, especially following the Cold War. Institutional frameworks, particularly in corporate and academic settings, have adopted vague terminology that obscures clear political analysis. This ambiguity allows elites to manipulate discourse, perpetuating a divide between competing cultural identities rather than addressing underlying economic inequalities. The conflation of woke culture with traditional political ideologies undermines genuine understanding of power dynamics in society.
Equity as a Tool for Maintaining Economic Inequality
The contemporary focus on equity is critiqued as a means to reinforce existing disparities instead of dismantling them. By prioritizing racial and gender representation within the structures of capitalism, the narrative suggests that actual economic equality becomes sidelined. This approach is portrayed as a strategy to satisfy elite interests while deflecting attention from broader issues of class struggle. The argument posits that true reform should aim at dismantling the systems that create and sustain wealth disparities, rather than merely redistributing positions of power.
The Role of Identity Politics in Economic Division
The podcast outlines how identity politics serves to distract from economic inequalities by focusing on racial and gender issues. This segmentation prevents the formation of coalitions across different socioeconomic backgrounds that would challenge the status quo. By highlighting the disproportionate representation of various identity groups without addressing class issues, the media and political narratives exacerbate tensions that benefit those in power. The criticism extends to anti-racism initiatives that inadvertently entrench divisions instead of fostering solidarity among the economically disadvantaged.
When ideas and movements that threaten to overturn established hierarchies of power are absorbed into elite institutions like Ivy League universities and for-profit corporations, they get transformed into ideas that support the status quo, while remaining cloaked in the language and symbols of radicalism and egalitarianism.
The replacement of the word “equality” by the word “equity” in the worlds of academia, NGOs, activism, and corporate HR departments, is an example of the attempts by elite people and institutions to transform historical movements for racial and gender equality, into ideas that promote the interest of elites – in particular, economic inequality and the division of the working classes.
In this episode we explore how forms of oppression based on cultural factors like skin colour or gender or religion, etc, can only be understood and effectively combatted by understanding them in the context of economic exploitation and economic competition which is what the human propensity to discriminate evolved for in the first place.
PLEASE SHARE AND LET PEOPLE KNOW ABOUT THIS SERIES!!
I purposefully don’t monetize my channel in order to spare you the annoying ads, and it takes me weeks to make these (this one took almost 3 months!), so please help if you can!