Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz, an Indigenous historian and activist, and Nick Estes, a noted Indigenous historian and writer, discuss the real history behind Thanksgiving and Indigenous struggles. They critique the romanticized narratives surrounding the holiday, calling for a reevaluation of American nationalism. The conversation delves into issues like colonial atrocities, the fight for Indigenous rights, and the ongoing impacts of intergenerational trauma. They also explore the importance of authentic representation of Native cultures in history and media.
The podcast highlights the importance of recognizing how mainstream narratives surrounding Thanksgiving erase Indigenous histories and experiences of violence.
Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz illustrates that U.S. origin stories prioritize colonial perspectives, contributing to the ongoing marginalization of Native voices.
The ongoing struggles for Native American rights, such as land sovereignty and justice, emphasize the need for preserving Indigenous stories against colonial practices.
The episode addresses the urgency of the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls movement, showcasing the heightened violence against Native women.
Indigenous activism, particularly through digital platforms, plays a crucial role in unifying communities and reclaiming narratives while fostering awareness of historical injustices.
Deep dives
Historical Context of Native American Displacement
The episode highlights the historical context of Native American storytelling, tracing from Columbus's arrival to modern-day experiences. It emphasizes how the U.S. has often conveyed a narrative that sidelines Native voices, especially during mainstream holidays like Thanksgiving, which is framed as a celebration while ignoring the genocidal underpinnings of American expansion. Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz discusses the origin stories of the U.S. that prioritize colonial narratives, illustrating how these celebrations stem from violence and dispossession. By revisiting these historical moments, the episode urges listeners to recognize the ongoing impact of this history on Indigenous peoples today.
The Legacy of Violence Against Native Peoples
The podcast delves into the systematic violence faced by Native American tribes, particularly in California, as settlers moved in during the Gold Rush. Historical accounts reveal how the discovery of gold accelerated violence against Native tribes, with state-sanctioned genocidal campaigns aimed at eliminating Indigenous presence. Mention is made of specific events, like the killing of Pomo and Wapo individuals due to their resistance against white settlers, highlighting the brutal responses from vigilantes and the military. This legacy of violence serves as a stark reminder of the consequences of colonialism that persist in contemporary society.
The Social Impact of Historical Narratives
The podcast examines how the dominant narratives surrounding Thanksgiving and American history have been crafted to erase and mythologize the experiences of Native peoples. Dunbar-Ortiz contends that these narratives create a disconnect between the true history of colonial violence and the celebratory rhetoric of the holiday. She argues that recognizing the reality behind these myths is essential for social change and understanding the impact of colonialism on both Native and non-Native communities. This discussion demonstrates that historical narratives shape social consciousness and relationships with Indigenous peoples.
Continuing Struggles for Indigenous Rights
Listeners are informed about the modern struggles Native Americans continue to face, such as the fight for recognition and justice on issues such as land rights and the effects of historical policies like the Dawes Act. The episode points out how tribal sovereignty remains under constant threat and emphasizes the importance of preserving Native stories and cultures against a backdrop of ongoing colonial practices. Additionally, the discussion about Indigenous Peoples Day and events like the National Day of Mourning reflects the ongoing resistance against state narratives. This sheds light on how modern activism is essential for reclaiming Indigenous identities and rights.
Challenges of Indigenous Women
The podcast sheds light on the rampant violence against Indigenous women, emphasizing that Native women are at a heightened risk of domestic violence, assault, and murder. Statistics provided indicate that a significant portion of Native women experience violence in their lifetimes, illustrating an urgent need for action and awareness surrounding this crisis. The discussion includes the notion of intergenerational trauma stemming from historical injustices, reinforcing the complexity of addressing violence against Native women today. The MMIWG movement (Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls) is further discussed, highlighting the need for solidarity and advocacy to combat this epidemic.
Historical Misconceptions and the Doctrine of Discovery
The episode explores the Doctrine of Discovery and its implications on the rights and recognition of Native American sovereignty. The historical context provided illustrates how European colonizers, including the U.S. government, rationalized the acquisition of land occupied by Native peoples through religious and legal doctrines. Dunbar-Ortiz explains how this doctrine allowed for the systemic dispossession and marginalization of Indigenous communities, and how its implications are still felt today. Challenging these misconceptions is crucial for advancing understanding and justice for Native peoples and cultures.
Legacies of Colonial Narratives
The podcast narratively critiques the persistence of colonial narratives that continue to shape the American identity and how they often erase Indigenous experiences. It interrogates how holidays like Thanksgiving serve to perpetuate myths surrounding the 'peaceful' encounter between settlers and Native peoples. These narratives contribute to a broader societal ignorance of the violent histories of colonization that impact contemporary relations with Indigenous communities. By recognizing these harmful legacies, the could lead to a more honest and just society that honors the truth of Indigenous histories.
Indigenous Activism and Cultural Resilience
The discussion highlights a growing movement of Indigenous activism, emphasizing the importance of cultural resilience and storytelling in the fight for rights. Examples from events such as Standing Rock exemplify how these movements serve not only to protect land but foster unity among Indigenous peoples. These grassroots efforts are depicted as a continuation of the historical resistance against colonialism, demonstrating that Native communities are reclaiming their narratives and identities. The episode asserts the necessity of supporting these movements as a means of addressing both historical and contemporary injustices faced by Native peoples.
The Power of Digital Spaces in Indigenous Activism
The podcast emphasizes how digital spaces have become critical for Indigenous activism, allowing for connections across geographical boundaries. It discusses how social media platforms facilitate the sharing of stories, mobilization of support, and dissemination of information around Indigenous issues. This newfound connectivity is contrasted with historical isolation, highlighting the role of technology in empowering Indigenous communities today. By utilizing digital spaces, Native activists can raise awareness and advocate for social justice, allowing their voices to reach wider audiences and facilitate lasting change.
Revisiting Historical Legacies for the Future
The episode concludes with a call for listeners to reevaluate their understanding of American history in light of the legacies of colonialism. Revisiting these historical narratives fosters awareness and compassion toward Native peoples while driving home the importance of supporting contemporary Indigenous movements. Additionally, there lies a connection between collective memory and modern activism, encouraging communities to take ownership of their histories. By doing so, listeners can play a role in the broader effort to address injustice and cultivate a more inclusive narrative that honors Native lives and experiences.
Today’s episode is a remix of a 5-part series of episodes we did several years ago about telling native stories beyond what the US tends to share about its history. The series stretched all the way from Columbus to modern day and today we’re sharing the highlights reel of what stuck out to us looking back.
Be part of the show! Leave us a message or text at 202-999-3991 or email Jay@BestOfTheLeft.com
