Fr. Gregory Pine O.P. discusses the ethics of lying, emphasizing the importance of genuine conversations. The podcast explores biblical teachings on honesty and delves into the distinctions between types of lies. It challenges the view of morality tied only to religious actions and advocates for responses rooted in moral creativity. The guest also explores moral dilemmas in holding onto beliefs during adversity.
St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas assert that lying is always wrong, emphasizing the importance of truthfulness rooted in justice.
The podcast encourages moral creativity when facing dilemmas like lying to protect others, advocating for virtue and integrity.
Deep dives
Exploring Rome's Intellectual Tradition at Pontifical University
College students have a unique chance to delve into Rome's intellectual tradition at the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas through the Thomistic Institute's study abroad programs. The programs offer a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to explore this rich heritage, with limited sponsorships available for the spring 2025 semester. Those interested can find more information on the Thomistic Institute's website.
The Teaching of St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas on Lying
St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas assert that lying is always wrong, presenting a controversial claim that lies should be avoided as there are no valid reasons to lie. They emphasize the importance of truthfulness, a virtue rooted in justice, highlighting the fundamental principle of not bearing false witness.
Different Types of Lies: Malicious, Jacose, and Officious
The podcast dissects various types of lies, categorizing them as malicious, jacose, and officious. Malicious lies are deemed severe, told with the intent to harm others. Jacose lies are told for amusement, while officious lies are of lesser gravity, often intended to help individuals. These distinctions shed light on the varying moral implications of lying.
Navigating Moral Dilemmas and Virtuous Responses
When faced with moral dilemmas like lying to protect others, the podcast encourages moral creativity and prudent decision-making. Emphasizing the pursuit of virtue and integrity, it underscores the importance of upholding one's word and remaining true to one's beliefs. By engaging with theological and philosophical insights, listeners are challenged to navigate complex moral scenarios with a principled approach.