How Home Insurance and Climate Change are Upending the Real Estate Market
Feb 19, 2025
auto_awesome
Dr. Jeremy Porter, an expert in environmental health sciences, discusses the alarming impact of climate change on home insurance and real estate values. He highlights how insurers are withdrawing from high-risk states, which threatens homeownership and economic stability. The conversation covers climate-driven migration patterns, the challenges of rising premiums, and the growing awareness of environmental hazards. Porter emphasizes the need for better climate risk data and questions the future of wealth tied to real estate in an increasingly unstable environment.
Rising insurance rates due to climate change are drastically affecting property values, posing a financial threat to homeowners and communities.
Climate-driven migration patterns are evolving as residents prioritize safety, leading to shifts in housing demand toward lower-risk areas.
State-established insurers of last resort are emerging in high-risk regions, yet they struggle to provide long-term solutions to the underlying climate issues.
Deep dives
The Impact of Climate Change on Housing Insurance
Climate change is significantly influencing housing insurance, particularly in regions vulnerable to natural disasters like hurricanes and wildfires. Insurance companies are increasingly withdrawing coverage or raising rates drastically in high-risk areas, with State Farm and Allstate ceasing to issue new policies in California due to catastrophic risk. This trend signals a broader reality where climate risks are reflected in insurance pricing, warning homeowners that these costs may outstrip their ability to afford coverage. Consequently, escalating insurance costs are becoming a critical indicator of property values, as potential buyers assess the affordability of living in at-risk regions.
Economic Consequences of Declining Property Values
Rising insurance premiums are leading to declining property values, which have far-reaching economic implications for communities. As insurance costs rise, many homeowners find it challenging to maintain their properties, leading to a decrease in home equity and household wealth. This, in turn, undermines local economic activity as reduced property taxes limit funding for vital community infrastructure and services. The cycle of decreasing property values and increasing insurance premiums threatens the economic viability of entire neighborhoods, compelling residents to relocate to more stable areas.
Regional Migration Trends Driven by Climate Risk
As climate change continues to shift risk profiles, migration patterns within the U.S. are evolving significantly. Areas previously considered desirable, such as parts of Texas and Florida, face challenges from extreme heat and flooding, prompting residents to move inland or to less risky locales. Research indicates that many individuals are already prioritizing safety in housing decisions, favoring properties at higher elevations or away from coastal flooding risks. This internal migration reflects a broader trend where climate risks become a primary factor influencing where people choose to live and invest.
The Role of State-Run Insurance Programs
In response to rising insurance costs and declining availability of private policies, several states have established insurers of last resort to cover residents. This approach aims to provide necessary coverage in areas deemed too risky for private insurers to operate sustainably. However, these state-run plans often face significant financial strains, particularly following major disaster events that deplete their reserves. Critics argue that while these programs offer temporary relief, they do not address the underlying issues caused by climate change and may not offer sufficient long-term solutions.
Repercussions on Wealth and Economic Security
The real estate market's response to climate change is expected to challenge traditional notions of wealth accumulation through homeownership. As climate risks increase and affect property values, many Americans may find their primary asset—home equity—under threat, ultimately complicating their financial security. This shift raises critical questions about the future of the American dream of homeownership, as ownership may no longer guarantee wealth-building potential. Furthermore, as homeowners grapple with these changing dynamics, an increasing burden will be placed on renters who may face rising rents as landlords seek to pass on insurance costs, deepening economic inequalities.
The average middle class family has 67% of their net worth tied up in its primary residence. But there’s one looming issue: Rising insurance rates and climate change are threatening those property values—and they might be the canary in the coal mine of the American Dream.
We’re joined by Dr. Jeremy Porter, author of the First Street report at the center of most recent insurance analyses. We discuss insurers pulling out of “high-risk” states, “insurers of last resort” in those states, climate-driven migration patterns we’re already seeing, and how this is likely to play out over the next few decades.
So yes, this episode is about real estate, insurance, and climate risk—but it’s also about the assumptions underpinning wealth in America, and what it means if they’re changing.
Money with Katie’s mission is to be the intersection where the economic, cultural, and political meet the tactical, practical, personal finance education everyone needs.