Planet: Critical
The "Energy Transition" is a Pipe Dream | Jean-Baptiste Fressoz
Mar 20, 2025
Jean-Baptiste Fressoz, historian of science and technology and author of 'More and More', discusses the complexities surrounding energy transition. He argues that every new energy source increases overall consumption rather than replacing existing ones. Fressoz critiques the misconceptions surrounding decarbonization and the historical roots of the 'energy transition' concept, once a scientific term turned policy fantasy. He emphasizes the importance of acknowledging systemic inequality in climate discussions and advocates for a more nuanced approach to sustainability.
51:51
Episode guests
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- The podcast critiques the notion of a seamless energy transition, arguing instead that historical energy consumption shows an increase in material use rather than a linear switch between sources.
- It stresses the necessity for public engagement in climate policy discussions, advocating for meaningful debates around ethical CO2 emissions and practical solutions like promoting train travel over domestic flights.
Deep dives
Redefining Energy Transition History
The discussion challenges the conventional narrative of energy transition, suggesting it is rooted in a false history. Instead of viewing energy development as a linear shift from one source to another, the reality highlights a symbiotic expansion of various energies. For instance, the Industrial Revolution did not lead to a decrease in wood consumption with the discovery of coal; rather, there was an overall increase in the use of raw materials. Such insights underscore the importance of retelling the history of energy based on material realities rather than outdated technological narratives.
