Raphael Geiger, Istanbul correspondent for Süddeutsche Zeitung, discusses the recent protests in Turkey following President Erdogan's controversial arrest of Istanbul's mayor, Ekrem Imamoglu. Highlighting youth-led movements, he emphasizes the aspiration for democracy amidst governmental oppression. Meanwhile, Henry Bodkin, a Jerusalem correspondent, delves into the political unrest in Israel, sparked by Netanyahu's actions and the firing of Shin Bet's director. This conversation uncovers the alarming erosion of democratic values in both nations.
The arrest of Istanbul's mayor has ignited widespread protests, highlighting a growing public discontent with Erdogan's authoritarian governance.
Despite Erdogan's control, there is an emerging desire among younger generations for political reform and democratic accountability in Turkey.
Deep dives
Erdogan's Political Crackdown in Turkey
The recent arrest of Istanbul's mayor, Ekrem Imamoglu, has triggered widespread protests across Turkey, signaling public dissent against President Erdogan's regime. Imamoglu's imprisonment on corruption charges, which he asserts are politically motivated, has intensified fears about the future of democracy in the country. The protests have drawn diverse groups, including nationalists and students, indicating a broader societal frustration with Erdogan's prolonged rule. The protests mark a significant moment for younger generations who have only known Erdogan as their leader, creating a growing sentiment that political change may be on the horizon.
Youth Sentiment and Erdogan's Support Base
Despite ongoing protests, Erdogan maintains a substantial support base, primarily due to his strategic control over public payrolls and institutions. However, younger interviewees express a lack of hope for economic improvement, with many contemplating emigration. This generation, having never experienced a leadership change, is increasingly vocal about its desire for political reform. Observers note a shift in sentiment, suggesting that while Erdogan's authority appears strong, his popular support could falter if elections were held today.
The Impact of Erdogan's Policies
Erdogan's governance has led to increased frustration surrounding Turkey's democracy and its rule of law, with protests spreading to smaller municipalities traditionally supportive of him. As public unrest grows, the government's heavy-handed response raises concerns about possible escalating violence and further crackdowns on dissent. Veteran activists warn that while protests have happened in the past without major changes, the current wave of demonstrations feels notably different, driven by a collective yearning for change. Citizens fear the emerging authoritarianism could solidify into a new normal, diminishing the prospects for democratic governance.
Geopolitical Context and Turkey's Future
Erdogan's recent confidence is partly derived from Turkey's geopolitical significance, as he plays a pivotal role in discussions surrounding regions like Ukraine and Syria. This perceived strength has diminished international pressure on Erdogan, emboldening his domestic actions, including crackdowns on political rivals. Observers suggest that the current situation may worsen Turkey's ongoing economic crisis, with investor confidence likely to decline amidst increasing instability. If citizens feel their right to elect representatives is eroding, it will likely fuel a more pronounced push for reform and accountability from political leaders.
Turkey and Israel: two Middle Eastern democracies in crisis. Venetia Rainey talks to Süddeutsche Zeitung journalist Raphael Geiger in Istanbul about why President Recep Tayyep Erdogan's arrest of the city's mayor Ekrem Imamoglu has sparked rare protests, and what might happen next.
Henry Bodkin, our correspondent in Israel, explains how the sacking of Ronen Bar, the head of the internal security agency Shin Bet, has sparked fears that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is consolidating unprecedented power and removing critics.
Read:
'Netanyahu spy scandal leaves PM fighting on two fronts' by Henry Bodkin: