The U.S. Diplomatic Response in Gaza with Akbar Shahid Ahmed and Robbie Gramer
Oct 27, 2023
auto_awesome
Akbar Shahid Ahmed and Robbie Gramer discuss the US diplomatic response to the Gaza conflict, including the broken Senate confirmation process, high-level diplomatic resignations, potential mutiny in the State Department, and the impact of a circulating dissent cable. They also talk about the importance of protecting personal information online and delve into strategies and concerns in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
There is growing dissatisfaction and dissent among members of the US State Department regarding the Biden administration's handling of the Israel-Palestine conflict.
The US diplomatic corps faces significant challenges in its response to the Israel-Hamas conflict due to numerous vacancies and shortcomings in the Senate confirmation process.
The US diplomatic response to the Israel-Palestine conflict has been accelerated and intensified following a deadly attack by Hamas.
Deep dives
Dissent at the State Department
There is growing dissatisfaction and dissent among members of the US State Department regarding the Biden administration's handling of the Israel-Palestine conflict. Diplomats feel that their expertise and policy advice are being overlooked and that there is a lack of diversity of perspective in decision-making. The internal tensions have been exacerbated by the high-profile resignation of Josh Paul, a veteran State Department official. There are also concerns about the politicization of the dissent channel process, with House Republicans seizing on dissent cables to advance their own political agendas. The internal dissent and dissatisfaction indicate a potential shift in the traditionally unwavering support for Israel within the National Security establishment.
Vacancies and Challenges in Diplomatic Response
The US diplomatic corps faces significant challenges in its response to the Israel-Hamas conflict due to numerous vacancies and shortcomings in the Senate confirmation process. Many key diplomatic posts in the Middle East, including Israel and Egypt, remain vacant, hampering the ability to respond effectively. The slow confirmation process combined with a thin bench of experienced diplomats limits the US' ability to navigate the crisis and handle the diplomatic fallout. The shortage of diplomatic heavyweights and leadership positions creates internal constraints and weakens the US diplomatic response overall.
US Diplomatic Response and Israel-Palestine Conflict
The US diplomatic response to the Israel-Palestine conflict has been accelerated and intensified following a deadly attack by Hamas. The diplomatic posts in the Middle East were caught off guard, as the Biden administration initially focused on other global issues. Top US officials, including Jake Sullivan and Secretary of State Blinken, have made visits to the region to assess the situation and engage in diplomacy. The response is aimed at evaluating the US' diplomatic role in the conflict, managing the crisis, and mitigating the humanitarian consequences of the conflict. The US is also facing internal challenges and dissent regarding its approach to supporting Israel and addressing the humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
Internal Challenges and Dissent within the State Department
The State Department is facing internal challenges and dissent among its diplomats regarding the handling of the Israel-Palestine conflict. There is a culture of silence, inhibition, and a perceived lack of influence within the department, leading to frustration and dissatisfaction among diplomats. The dissent channel, a mechanism for diplomats to express their objections or concerns, has been utilized with a cable circulating within the State Department expressing opposition to the US policy on the conflict. The internal challenges and debates reflect broader concerns about the lack of diversity in perspectives and decision-making within the State Department.
The Importance of Data Brokerage and DeleteMe
Data brokerage and the market for personal information are contributing to increased risks of privacy invasion, harassment, and identity theft. Personal information captured by data brokers, including social security numbers, addresses, and family details, is packaged and sold to interested parties. The risk of being targeted and the exposure to various threats can be mitigated through services like DeleteMe. DeleteMe removes personal listings and reduces the attack surface for potential threats. The service regularly reports on its activities and provides users with a dashboard. DeleteMe offers a special offer discount for Lawfare podcast listeners.
It’s probably fair to say that the Israeli government was not the only one caught flat-footed by the deadly attack launched by Hamas on Oct. 7. On that day, several of the U.S. government’s top diplomatic posts in the Middle East were vacant, and the Biden administration had long focused most of its attention elsewhere in the world. And, in a now infamous episode from only a week prior to the attack, National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan had said, “The Middle East region is quieter today than it has been in two decades.”
But all that has changed. Though its record is still up for debate, the U.S. diplomatic response has kicked into gear, with several visits to the region from Sullivan, Secretary of State Blinken, President Biden, and other high-level U.S. officials.
To take stock of the U.S. diplomatic response to the war thus far, Lawfare Managing Editor Tyler McBrien sat down with Akbar Shahid Ahmed, HuffPost's senior foreign affairs reporter, and Robbie Gramer, a diplomacy and national security reporter at Foreign Policy. They talked about the nearly broken Senate confirmation process, the fallout from a high-level diplomatic resignation, and the potential “mutiny brewing” inside the State Department. They also discussed whether or not a reported dissent cable circulating through the department might shift U.S. policy toward Israel-Palestine.