The Commentary Magazine Podcast Who Are the 'Palestine Firsters'?
11 snips
Dec 16, 2025 
Eli Lake, a seasoned journalist and contributing editor known for his critical insights, explores the concept of 'Palestine Firsters' and its implications for U.S.-Israel relations. He argues that this stance undermines American security interests amidst rising tensions. Lake critiques humanitarian narratives that neglect Hamas's role, delves into the historical roots of 'Israel first' accusations, and highlights the strategic benefits of a strong Israel. The conversation also touches on addiction and societal responses, tying in broader themes of policy and responsibility.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Chabad Menorah On Lexington Avenue
- John Podhoretz recounts seeing Chabad members singing by a menorah on the Upper East Side.
- He contrasts that image with news of a later subway attack on Chabad worshippers.
'Palestine Firsters' Reframes The Debate
- Eli Lake coins 'Palestine Firsters' to describe critics who prioritize Palestinian political outcomes over U.S. national interest.
- He argues this stance neglects how the U.S.-Israel alliance advances security goals like countering Iran.
Israel's Campaign Seen As U.S. Strategic Gain
- Lake contends Israel's military actions since October 7th served broader U.S. interests by degrading Iran's program and Sunni militant capabilities.
- He says critics who push immediate ceasefires ignore strategic consequences for American security.