Intelligence Squared Archive: Debate – The Left has right on its side
May 26, 2024
In a thought-provoking discussion, George Monbiot, a political and environmental columnist, engages with Conservative MP Kwasi Kwarteng, philosopher Roger Scruton, and Labour MP Stella Creasy. They tackle the ideological divide between left and right, debating the ideals of equality and collective action. The conversation explores the implications of socialism, critiques corporate power, and examines wealth inequality. Personal stories shed light on family dynamics and societal values, encouraging a reassessment of political beliefs.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Left vs. Right and Power
- The escalating concentration of wealth and power is an intrinsic characteristic of complex societies.
- The left's role is to break this cycle, while the right seeks to protect it.
Social Mobility and Mutual Aid
- Roger Scruton's family rose from poverty through mutual aid societies, not state intervention.
- He highlights the role of voluntary associations like the British Medical Association in providing healthcare before the NHS.
Beyond Wealth Distribution
- Roger Scruton argues that wealth distribution is not the only important political issue.
- He emphasizes the importance of freedom, social mobility, and the right to own and exchange property.
