Discussing the dangers faced by democracy, the historical influence of demagogues, analogies of statesmen and demagogues in politics, navigating modern challenges with stoicism, handling rhetoric and cognitive distancing, and managing anger and political influence with Stoicism.
Stoicism offers tools to combat manipulative influences on democracy through rational thinking and moral correction.
Understanding the historical origins of political manipulation can help in identifying and countering modern-day sophistry in public discourse.
Deep dives
Donald Robertson's Background and Work in Philosophy and Psychology
Donald Robertson discusses his background as a Scottish cognitive behavioral therapist and clinical supervisor with a degree in philosophy. He highlights his journey from a specialized focus on the relationship between philosophy and psychotherapy, once considered niche, to the rise in popularity of stoicism. Robertson shares his experience writing books on philosophy, history, psychotherapy, and self-improvement and describes the challenge of categorizing his books into a single genre.
Stoicism and Its Relevance in Modern Democracy
Robertson delves into the relevance of stoicism in modern democracy by exploring the potential of stoicism to address threats faced by democratic systems today. He draws parallels between historical political figures like Cleon in ancient Athens and contemporary challenges posed by technology and rhetoric in influencing public opinion. Robertson emphasizes the importance of integrating philosophy, rational thinking, and moral correction to combat manipulative influences on democracy.
The Influence of Ancient Sophists and Modern Political Rhetoric
Robertson discusses the influence of ancient sophists like Herodis Atticus in shaping persuasive rhetoric and manipulative political discourse. He draws connections between the historical practices of sophistry and modern-day political manipulation through marketing, social media, and news media. Robertson highlights the dangers of selective information, cognitive fusion, and the role of cognitive distancing in safeguarding against misleading rhetoric and sophistry.
Stoic Strategies for Rational Thinking and Emotional Control
Robertson explores stoic strategies, including cognitive distancing and recognizing early warning signs of emotional manipulation. He emphasizes Marcus Aurelius' teachings on separating beliefs from emotions and the importance of questioning overgeneralizations prevalent in political rhetoric. Robertson suggests using Socratic methods to identify moral contradictions, challenge hypocrisy, and maintain rational perspectives amidst emotional manipulation in political discourse.
This special episode contains a live recording of my recent talk for Conversations with Modern Stoicism, hosted by Phil Yanov. We were celebrating Marcus Aurelius’ birthday, and I spoke at length about what I think we can learn from ancient Greece about the dangers faced by democracy, and how Socrates and the Stoics could help us. I was speaking live from Athens, the birthplace of democracy. Thanks to Phil Yanov, for providing the audio recording for this podcast episode.
Stoicism: Philosophy as a Way of Life is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Thank you for reading Stoicism: Philosophy as a Way of Life. This post is public so feel free to share it.