In this discussion, Jane Marie, a Peabody and Emmy Award-winning journalist known for her work on multi-level marketing, offers a deep dive into the troubling realities of MLMs. She unpacks the allure of these schemes, particularly their appeal to women, and reveals the financial traps participants often fall into. The conversation sheds light on the deceptive practices within MLMs, including misleading income statements and emotional manipulation. Jane also explores the historical roots and regulatory challenges these companies face, providing a comprehensive view of this controversial industry.
The emotional appeal and community support in MLMs often mask the grim reality of their recruitment-driven model, which leads to widespread financial loss among participants.
MLM companies frequently utilize misleading income disclosure statements that highlight a few success stories while concealing the high failure rates of the majority.
Deep dives
Overview of Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) Structure
Multi-level marketing (MLM) companies are characterized by a structure where individuals sell products while simultaneously recruiting new sellers into the business. The focus of MLMs is often on recruiting rather than direct sales of products, creating a pyramid-like system where profits predominantly flow upwards. Participants typically pay a sign-up fee and are then encouraged to purchase large amounts of inventory, which may lead to substantial personal expenses without guaranteed sales. This recruitment-heavy model highlights the mathematical impossibility for most participants to succeed, as the number of recruits needed far exceeds the available market.
The Role of Emotional Appeal and Community Support
MLMs often utilize emotional appeals and community support to attract and retain members, creating a sense of belonging among participants. Many MLM companies promote a culture of shared success and financial freedom, appealing to individuals seeking flexible working conditions. This emotional manipulation can be particularly compelling in economically depressed areas, where limited job opportunities make MLMs seem like an attractive option. For many women involved, attending MLM meetings and parties serves as a social outlet and an opportunity to find fulfillment beyond traditional family roles.
The Impact of Income Disclosure Statements
Income disclosure statements presented by MLMs frequently fail to provide a complete picture, which can mislead new recruits about their earning potential. These statements typically highlight success stories while obscuring the high failure rates among participants, with estimates showing that up to 97% of MLM members make little to no money. The FTC has examined numerous MLMs for deceptive practices in their income disclosures, revealing that unsuccessful members are often omitted from these reports. This lack of transparency contributes to a cycle of false hope, which continues to ensnare individuals seeking financial success through MLM involvement.
Historical Context and Regulation of MLMs
The history of MLMs can be traced back to early models like Tupperware, which initially offered legitimate business opportunities but eventually evolved into more scheme-like structures. Key companies such as Amway have successfully navigated legal challenges and continue to thrive, largely due to political connections and lax regulatory oversight. The FTC has previously taken action against various MLMs, but the success of Amway's defense in court set a precedent that has made it difficult for the government to impose strict regulations. Consequently, the MLM industry remains largely unregulated, and the cycle of recruitment and economic exploitation persists.
In this Money Talks: Jane Marie has spent years reporting on the tangled web of multi-level marketing companies, or MLMs, with her podcast The Dream and dives even deeper in her new book, Selling the Dream: The Billion-Dollar Industry Bankrupting Americans. In this episode, she sits down with Emily Peck to discuss their origins, their appeal to American women, and their extremely questionable business practices.
Want to hear that discussion and hear more Slate Money? Join Slate Plus to unlock weekly bonus episodes. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the Slate Money show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/moneyplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Jessamine Molli and Cheyna Roth.