This 100-year-old pattern explains Trump’s victory
Nov 20, 2024
auto_awesome
Lubos Pastor, a Chicago Booth professor focused on the nexus of economics and voting, discusses the surprising patterns behind Trump’s election victory. He argues that voters understood the economy was growing, which actually propelled them to seek change. The conversation reveals a century-old trend: strong economies tend to favor Republican candidates while weak ones favor Democrats. Pastor also highlights how risk attitudes shape voter behavior and contrasts stock market performance under different presidencies, emphasizing its historical complexities.
Voters recognize strong economic conditions but still seek political change, revealing a nuanced understanding of their financial situations and risk preferences.
A historical pattern indicates that a strong economy leads to increased support for Republican candidates, while economic struggles favor Democrats, driven by voter risk tolerance.
Deep dives
Voter Perception of the Economy
Voters demonstrate a strong ability to perceive the state of the economy, often voting according to their understanding of their individual circumstances rather than solely on external economic indicators. In the case of Donald Trump's election, many voters acknowledged that the economy was performing well, yet still opted for a change in leadership. Research indicates that during strong economic conditions, voters become more risk-tolerant, leading them to favor Republicans who advocate for lower taxes and less redistribution. This reflects a deeper understanding among voters, countering media narratives that suggest confusion regarding economic conditions.
The Strong Economy vs. Incumbency Thesis
Historical data shows a consistent pattern where a strong economy typically favors Republican candidates, while a weak economy leads voters to support Democrats, regardless of incumbency. This model, supported by a century of electoral data, implies that people's risk aversion plays a critical role in their voting preferences. When the economy is strong, voters are more willing to take risks and align with Republican values that emphasize individual financial freedom. Conversely, in times of economic struggle, voters tend to prefer Democratic policies that offer more social safety nets and economic redistribution.
Stock Market Performance and Political Affiliation
There exists a notable trend where stock market performance tends to be higher under Democratic presidents than Republican ones. This phenomenon arises not from the actions of the presidents themselves but from the economic conditions under which they are elected. During economic downturns, risk aversion is high, leading voters to choose Democrats, just as low-risk environments prompt Republican victories. Thus, the dynamics of economic risk and voter behavior explain much of the variations in stock market performance linked to the party in power.
Donald Trump’s victory in the presidential election took many pundits by surprise. Voters consistently said the economy was their top issue, but even though the US economy is currently the world’s top performer, they nevertheless voted for a change in government. That led many observers to claim that Trump’s supporters had a warped view of the economy, concentrating more on inflation than on growth. Chicago Booth’s Lubos Pastor disagrees. His research suggests that voters knew the economy was growing, and that was, in fact, the very reason why they wanted a change of government. Pastor’s model is relatively simple: when the economy is strong economy, more voters opt for the Republican candidate in elections, while a weak economy favors Democrats. This pattern has held since 1927, regardless of the candidates or the incumbents. The reason has to do with how the economy shapes people’s attitudes to risk, which is also explains another phenomenon: the stock market performs much better under Democratic presidents than under Republicans.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode