Practical Stoicism

From Defense to War: A Stoic Response to America’s Rebrand

Sep 12, 2025
The podcast tackles the renaming of the U.S. Department of Defense to the Department of War through a Stoic lens. It contrasts true warrior values—justice, self-control, and wisdom—with a focus on destructive ambition. The discussion highlights how words influence values and critiques performative strength over genuine moral leadership. It stresses Stoicism’s emphasis on intention behind military actions and warns against the dangers of confusing spectacle with true virtue, reminding us that practicing humanity should be our ultimate goal.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Formative Conservative Upbringing

  • Tanner Campbell recounts his father's conservative view that government should focus on defense, not foreign wars.
  • That upbringing shaped his instinct that the military's primary role should be defensive and limited in scope.
INSIGHT

Hegseth's 'Warrior Ethos' Rhetoric

  • Pete Hegseth framed the rename as restoring a 'warrior ethos' and intentionality to force.
  • His rhetoric emphasizes victory, offense, and 'maximum lethality' over legal or moral restraint.
INSIGHT

Rhetoric Can Normalize Cruelty

  • Tanner contrasts performative militarism with Stoic virtues using historical and cultural examples.
  • He warns that rhetoric celebrating violence risks endorsing cruelty rather than justice.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app