In this engaging discussion, Paula Marantz Cohen, Dean Emerita at Drexel University and author of Talking Cure, explores the transformative power of conversation. She dives into the dynamics of familial chats versus casual banter, emphasizing genuine curiosity. Cohen examines gossip's detrimental impact on dialogue and highlights the joy of meaningful exchanges, especially during communal dining. Through anecdotes from sports commentary to Shakespeare discussion groups, she underscores the importance of listening and how conversations can civilize our interactions.
Family conversations foster intellectual growth and a supportive environment, contrasting with the disengagement often found in formal educational settings.
The significance of spontaneity in conversations is emphasized, highlighting that genuine dialogue emerges from a natural and comfortable rapport between participants.
Context plays a crucial role in facilitating meaningful dialogues, where social settings and shared meals enhance connection while allowing for easy escape if needed.
Deep dives
The Power of Conversation in Family Dynamics
Growing up in a family where conversation was highly encouraged creates an environment for intellectual growth and idea exchange. The speaker reflects on their own experience of a family dinner tradition, where discussing various topics was a norm, contrasting it with the disengagement often found in school settings. This dynamic fosters a sense of safety and comfort in expressing thoughts, unlike the challenges faced in high school social interactions. Recognizing the lack of genuine curiosity among peers during formative years highlights the unique value of family conversations in nurturing future conversational skills.
Theoretical Foundations of Engaging Conversations
The theoretical exploration of conversation reveals the significance of spontaneity and connection between participants. Concepts such as 'flow', introduced in modern discussions and traced back to earlier theories, emphasize the organic nature of meaningful dialogue. The idea that forgetting oneself is essential for genuine conversation poses a paradox, as it needs to happen without intentional effort. Effective conversation emerges from a comfortable rapport between parties, allowing for an organic interaction that deepens understanding.
The Role of Social Context in Conversations
The speaker discusses the importance of context, such as food and social settings, in facilitating meaningful conversations. Establishing a comfortable environment, whether in a bar or restaurant, plays a crucial role in promoting interaction while also allowing escape routes if the dialogue becomes unfulfilling. Despite the allure of coffee shops, these environments can impede conversation, as people often retreat into their digital worlds. The duality of sharing a meal and having a conversation symbolizes nourishment, both physically and intellectually.
Gossip vs. Constructive Conversation
The distinction between gossip and meaningful conversation is highlighted, pointing out the potential for gossip to undermine authentic connections among individuals. Although sharing tidbits about others can create superficial bonds, there remains a risk of drifting into negativity or judgment. The conversation suggests that discussing personalities or events can lead to an enriched understanding, rather than merely maligning others. A more constructive approach to dialogue entails exploring substance rather than indulging in idle speculation about others, preserving the integrity of conversational exchanges.
Learning from Literature: Conversation as an Art
Literature, specifically characters like Pierre from 'War and Peace,' serves as a model for approaching conversations with openness and depth. Instead of focusing on debating or convincing others, the essence lies in engaging with receptiveness, understanding the other person's perspective, and fostering genuine connections. The dialogue stresses that the cornerstone of a fulfilling conversation is mutual respect and listening, establishing an atmosphere where ideas can flourish without judgment. This perspective champions the notion that conversation is a humanizing act that embodies shared experiences and insights.
This is the 400th episode of Historically Thinking. And while it’s a podcast that focuses on history, and how historians and everyone else think about the past, I do that each week through conversation. For a long time I have really wanted to believe something that Plato wrote, that “Truth, as human reality, comes about only in conversation.”
So it’s fitting, I think, that we devote Episode 400 to having a conversation about conversation with Paula Marantz Cohen, author of Talking Cure: An Essay on the Civilizing Power of Conversation. In this stimulating book, Cohen travels over all the terrains of conversation, from familial conversations to the restaurants most conducive to good conversation; from gatherings of great conversationalists to surprisingly useful self-help books on conversations; and to gossip, and those little keys that somehow unlock what Samuel Johnson termed “solid conversation”.
Paula Marantz Cohen is Dean Emerita of the Pennoni Honors College and Distinguished Professor of English at Drexel University. Among her books are Of Human Kindness: What Shakespeare Teaches Us About Empathy and six novels, including Jane Austen in Boca, which is “Pride and Prejudice set in a Jewish retirement community in Boca Raton”; the literary mystery What Alice Knew: A Most Curious Tale of Henry James and Jack the Ripper; and Beatrice Bunson’s Guide to Romeo and Juliet, a novel for young adults.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
