The mystery of ‘it’ in English. The most dramatic moments in grammar history. Ghost Town Mad, the song
Mar 4, 2025
auto_awesome
Ever wondered why we say "It's raining"? Dive into the quirky logic behind the use of the word 'it' as a placeholder in English. Discover a dramatic punctuation duel from 1837 that pitted two law professors against one another, highlighting the lengths people will go for grammar. You'll be amused by a costly grammar mistake that had significant financial repercussions. Plus, enjoy a humorous musical twist with a listener's family slang – a delightful peek into how we communicate within families!
The English use of 'it' as a dummy subject ensures proper sentence structure, contrasting with languages like Spanish that don't require it.
Historical grammar conflicts, such as duels over punctuation marks and costly errors, illustrate the serious implications of grammatical rules.
Deep dives
The Role of 'It' in English Sentences
The use of the word 'it' in English serves as a grammatical placeholder, often not referring to any specific noun. This 'dummy subject' appears in sentences like 'It is raining,' where 'it' does not signify anything concrete but maintains the required subject-verb structure essential for proper sentence formation. In contrast to languages like Spanish, where the verb itself conveys full meaning without needing an additional subject, English demands both a subject and a verb, which results in the use of 'it.' This characteristic can make understanding English particularly unique, as many languages do not have an equivalent for this kind of placeholder.
Dramatic Grammar History
Historical grammar conflicts reveal that language and punctuation can incite extreme reactions, including duels and financial losses. A notorious incident from 1837 involved two French law professors who fought a sword duel over a punctuation mark, emphasizing how seriously individuals took grammar disputes. In another case, a misplaced comma in a U.S. tariff law led to a costly error, resulting in a $2 million loss for the government, which highlights the serious consequences that seemingly minor grammatical details can have. These stories serve as a reminder that grammar isn't just about rules; it can be intertwined with personal honor and even legal matters.
Fascinating Language Quirks
Various languages contain unique traits regarding the use of grammatical subjects, further distinguishing them from English. For example, pro-drop languages like Japanese and Mandarin often omit pronouns when context makes them clear, an approach not utilized in English. In Italian or Portuguese, verb conjugations can denote subjects effectively, eliminating the need for placeholder pronouns like 'it.' These differences showcase the rich diversity of language structures and their impact on communication styles, illustrating how grammar varies significantly across cultures.
1061. Ever wonder why we say "It's raining" even though "it" doesn't refer to anything? We explain the logic behind this quirky English rule. Then, we look at some of the most dramatic moments in grammar history, including a semicolon duel, a costly comma mistake, and a famous book with 5,000 typos.
The "dummy 'it'" segment is by Karen Lunde, a former Quick & Dirty Tips editor and digital pioneer who's been spinning words into gold since before cat videos ruled the internet. She created one of the first online writing workshops, and she's published thousands of articles on the art of writing. These days, she leads personal narrative writing retreats and helps writers find their voice. Visit her at ChanterelleStoryStudio.com.