3 and Out with John Middlekauff Massive Mailbag, Are the Packers for REAL, What's the future for the 49ers
Sep 13, 2025
In a lively mailbag session, the host dives into the Packers' surprising success and questions its sustainability. The discussion shifts to the 49ers, exploring how to navigate a challenging season plagued by injuries. Insights into the rise of mobile quarterbacks reshape the evaluation of player performance. There’s also a look at playoff predictions highlighting the Ravens and Bills. Finally, the pressures of quarterback injuries and coaching dynamics add another layer to the analysis of this evolving NFL landscape.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Don’t Overread One Game For QBs
- One game doesn't define a quarterback's career because real tests come in struggle and sustained play.
- JJ McCarthy showed traits (arm, mobility, placement) but mental and physical toughness remain the open questions.
Continuity Trumps Individual Executives
- Organizational continuity keeps franchises competitive even after leadership changes.
- John believes Ed Policy won't radically change the Packers' sustained success because the infrastructure and philosophy remain intact.
Defensive Lines Make Defenses
- An elite defensive line can create a top defense even if other units are average.
- John says dominant pass rush and run play reduce the need for perfection in the back six.