Left Melancholia and the Arab Political Subject w/ Nihal El Aasar
Nov 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Nihal El Aasar, an Egyptian researcher and writer based in London, dives into her essay "Left-wing Melancholia." She explores the varied responses of Arab nations to the ongoing crisis in Gaza, addressing the expectations placed on the Arab masses. The discussion highlights the intricate ties between counter-revolution in Egypt and Palestinian liberation, examined through key figures like Ghassan Kanafani. Nihal also sheds light on the concept of 'patient urgency' in political movements and the emerging grassroots activism within the Egyptian diaspora.
Responses to the genocide in Gaza reveal significant political paralysis among Arab populations, contrasting with the historical activism seen during past intifadas.
The concept of defeat is reframed in the podcast as an ongoing process shaping collective consciousness, urging activists to analyze past struggles within current contexts.
Deep dives
The Aftermath of October 7th
The political landscape in the Arab world has drastically shifted since October 7th, marking a turning point for the Arab Spring's political subjectivity. This event serves as a reminder that nostalgia for past uprisings is insufficient in the face of contemporary realities and repression. The author emphasizes the need to confront current political situations rather than romanticize earlier periods such as 2011 or the long 60s. By acknowledging the limitations imposed by current conditions, there is an opportunity to reassess strategies for political action and solidarity.
Responses to the Gaza Conflict
Responses to the ongoing genocide in Gaza vary significantly across different Arab nations, highlighting a complex interplay of political paralysis and collective expectations. The author discusses how some Arab populations have struggled to respond to Gaza's plight, drawing on historical precedents where events like the intifadas prompted strong public mobilizations. However, unprecedented political repression in Egypt has stifled significant public outcry, showcasing a stark contrast to previous eras of activism. This alarming trend reflects a deeper issue regarding the perceived role of Palestine in Arab identity and the expectations placed upon the masses.
Understanding Defeat through a Broader Framework
The concept of defeat is reframed not merely as a series of events but as an ongoing process tied to collective consciousness and historical contexts. Influential works referenced in the discussion emphasize how defeat shapes political subjectivity and cultural identity rather than being seen as isolated occurrences. This broader framework encourages a continuous evaluation of past and present struggles, linking significant defeats in Arab history to current circumstances in Egypt and beyond. By understanding defeat as an accumulation of experiences, activists can pursue a more nuanced approach to political engagement and advocacy.
Imperialism and the Struggle for Palestine
The discussion highlights how imperialism impacts both the Arab masses and the political structures within the region, often stifling authentic expressions of political agency. The author critiques the disconnect between Arab state narratives and those of the people, illustrating how recent events reveal this divergence. The dynamics of U.S. foreign policy, coupled with local political repression, heavily influence responses to Palestine, demonstrating a need for solidarity across borders. Analyzing these relationships allows movements in imperial core countries to contextualize their struggles alongside those of the Arab world, fostering a more robust global solidarity.
Nihal El Aasar discusses her recent essay, titled Left-wing Melancholia, which has been published as part of Parapraxis Magazine's Palestine issue.
In the essay Nihal explores the responses to the ongoing genocide in Gaza from people in other Arab countries. In her words “there have been certain weighted expectations for the Arab masses to react more strongly and urgently to this genocide. Some have heeded the call; some have tried and failed.” She draws on the work of people like Ghassan Kanafani, Nouri Gana, and friend of the podcast Hannah Proctor, to explore the relationship between counterrevolution in Egypt, US Imperialism, and Palestinian liberation through the lens of Arab political subjectivity.
Nihal El Aasar is an Egyptian researcher living in London. Her writing has been published by outlets such as Protean, Africa Is A Country, ArtReview, and elsewhere. Her essay can be found here: https://www.parapraxismagazine.com/articles/leftwing-melancholia
SUPPORT: www.buymeacoffee.com/redmedicine
Soundtrack by Mark Pilkington
Twitter: @red_medicine__
www.redmedicine.substack.com/
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode