Paul Evans discusses the disputed victory in the Assyrian campaign of 701 BCE and compares it to the War of 1812. They explore the complexities of interpreting historical events, the origins of Zion theology, and the intricacies of war aims throughout history. The discussion sheds light on Hezekiah's reign, ancient intelligence, and the impact of varying perspectives on historical narratives.
Historical narratives are shaped by the ideologies of combatants, leading to varied interpretations of events.
The biblical portrayal of Hezekiah's victory mythologizes his successes, emphasizing divine intervention and national triumph.
The subjective nature of victory in historical conflicts parallels the interpretations of Hezekiah's triumph over the Assyrians.
Deep dives
Hezekiah's Victorious War: A Davidic Connection
Hezekiah, a descendant of David, is portrayed in the biblical text as a victorious king who resisted the Philistines. This connection to David highlights his heroic qualities and distinguishes him from preceding kings. The portrayal of Hezekiah's successful reign, his survival in the face of Assyrian threats, and the prosperity of Judah under his rule all contribute to his positive image in the biblical narrative.
Perspective of Victory: The Mythologizing Process
The biblical account of Hezekiah's victory over the Assyrians quickly turns into a celebratory myth, showcasing God's intervention and Judah's divine triumph. The rejuvenation of Judah, the comparison to David, and the defeat of the oppressive Assyrian forces accentuate this mythologizing narrative, emphasizing the enduring legacy of Hezekiah's reign.
Hezekiah in the Deuteronomistic History
The portrayal of Hezekiah's successes and triumphs in the biblical text aligns with the themes and perspectives found in the Deuteronomistic History. The incorporation of Hezekiah's story within this larger historical framework reflects the theological and ideological concerns of the ancient Israelites, highlighting his significance as a key figure in the nation's narrative.
The War of 1812 Parallels: Divergent Perspectives on Victory
The contrasting viewpoints in the historical account of the War of 1812, where both sides claimed victory despite different outcomes, resonate with the complexities of interpreting Hezekiah's victory over the Assyrians. The subjective nature of victory and the nuanced historical perspectives underscore the multifaceted understanding of success in ancient military conflicts.
Reimagining Hezekiah's Triumph: An Early Commemoration
The immediacy and commemoration of Hezekiah's victory in the biblical text suggest an early theologizing process that honored his achievement as a divine and national triumph. The rapid mythologizing of events parallels the formation of celebratory narratives in contemporary history, highlighting the enduring impact of iconic victories in shaping historical memory.
Episode: In this episode of Biblical World, Kyle interviews Paul Evans about his new book, Sennacherib and the War of 1812: Disputed Victory in the Assyrian Campaign of 701 BCE in Light of Military History (T&T Clark, 2023). They delve into military history and consider how the goals and ideologies of individual combatants/nations lead to alternate narratives of how events unfolded and what those events meant. The ideas of what is "true" and "accurate" in historical reporting is given greater nuance by comparing Sennacherib's third campaign with the War of 1812.
Guest: Dr. Paul Evans is Associate Professor of Old Testament at McMaster Divinity College. Currently, Paul is writing a two-volume commentary on 1-2 Chronicles for The New International Commentary on the Old Testament NICOT series published by Eerdmans. Paul previously wrote a commentary on 1 & 2 Samuel published in the Story of God series by Zondervan. Paul’s earlier work includes a monograph entitled The Invasion of Sennacherib in the Book of Kings: A Source-Critical and Rhetorical Study of 2 Kings 18-19, which was awarded the 2010 R.B.Y. Scott Award by the Canadian Society of Biblical Studies recognizing an outstanding book in the areas of Hebrew Bible and/or the Ancient Near East. Paul’s most recent monograph, and the subject of this podcast episode, is entitled Sennacherib and the War of 1812: Historical Reconstructions of the Assyrian Campaign of 701 BCE in Light of Military History(Bloomsbury, 2023). In addition Paul has many research articles in print, with most focused on the historical books of the Old Testament. (from the McMaster Divinity website)
Give: Visit our Donate Page if you want to help Biblical World continue by becoming a one-off or regular donor.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode